Showing posts with label bad law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bad law. Show all posts

Wednesday, 25 September 2013

Moronic Mess from Miliband the Millionaire Marxist

Those of us interested in matters political feel a strange compunction to listen to speeches uttered by those who might be in position to turn their desires into law.  Today it was the turn of Miliband the Millionaire Marxist.  Today he showed what commentators on the radio seemed to consider his true colours.  

The speech itself was actually quite interesting with a sickly amalgam of sentimental sob stories, prices and income policies straight out of HG Wells' time machine, a novel variation on British Jobs for British Workers, proposals to nationalise land and wholescale criticism of the very policies he personally supported and put to the British people at the last two general elections (and some which he helped to create as a Labour Party policy advisor in the election of 2001). 

How refreshing it would be to hear a senior politician say "We introduced a policy which didn't work, we took a lot of advice, considered it carefully and thought it would work but we were wrong.  We are very sorry for our mistake and understand what you are entitled to doubt our judgment.  Nonetheless we now put forward a different policy and ask you to consider it carefully".  But no, for Miliband his previous policies are all the fault of the current government and he is and always has been right.  This fundamental and transparent dishonesty is displayed by the leaders of both main parties, less so by the leader of the third party, but is shown in full measure by the leader of the fourth party (the current Deputy Prime Minister).  One day they will realise people see through them and laugh at their inability to admit they make errors of judgment - we all do it, usually several times a day, and the absurdity of these superannuated oafs pretending to be different does them no favours.  

At the core of every one of Miliband's policy initiatives announced today is the belief that government has magical powers to influence the private sector economy for the good.  Now it goes without saying that different people will have different ideas of what is "for the good", but my point is valid regardless of anyones opinions on that.  You see, I ask what government can do and it is the answer to that question that explains why magic has nothing to do with it.  The answer is obvious provided you start from the correct position.  

The private sector comprises businesses providing goods and services (usually but not necessarily for profit).  By definition these businesses incur costs in making their goods and services available and can continue in business only for so long as the selling price matches or exceeds all the costs (they can, of course, run at a loss for a while but will eventually have to fold when lines of financial support are exhausted).  A business that makes a profit can do various things with it - retain profits for investment with a view to expanding the business, pay a dividend to investors and/or a bonus to staff, retain it to provide a cash buffer in case things turn south, give it to the Battersea Dogs' Home and more. 

From that starting point it becomes clear that the only things government policies can affect are costs, selling prices and profits.  Don't get it wrong, don't think government can do anything that affects a business other than to influence costs, selling prices or profits.  It cannot.  

We had examples of policies intended to affect all three of these in Mr Miliband's speech.  

Small businesses are to be taxed less.  The idea is to reduce costs by reducing the amount of tax that must be paid as everyday overheads.  He promotes this as a benefit being provided to small businesses by his government.  It is nothing of the sort.  He is proposing reducing an impediment to business that the current government, and the government of which he was previously a part, impose on business.  

He said this is a way to create more jobs.  For once I agree with him.  If you reduce the costs of business the prospect of profit is increased and, inevitably, so is the prospect of that business expanding and taking on additional staff.  The same applies to all cost imposed by government as overheads - land taxes, employer's National Insurance contributions, VAT and countless regulations that require expenditure to be incurred (usually pointlessly) on monitoring compliance with random targets and standards that have no substance beyond the egotistical commands of single-issue bigots. 

For big businesses he wants to take more of their profits in tax.  No reduction in costs for them, jobs that might be created by reducing the costs of big businesses are of no interest to him.  To the Millionaire Marxist big business is just a cash cow, to be milked and punished to the fullest extent possible.  How ironic it is that his plans require the big businesses he despises so much to make the largest profits possible.  

Having said that, taxes that apply before sales are made increase the prices businesses have to charge to break even.  An example I have given before is of a furniture manufacturer that spends £50 on raw materials and £50 on labour to create a table, leaving aside other overheads the table cannot be sold at £100 to achieve break-even.  Because VAT at 20% will have to be added the sale price must be £120.  There might not be a market at that level, although there might be at £105 or £110.  If you get rid of VAT and tax profits instead the business has an increased chance of expanding and creating more jobs.  Get rid of land tax (business rates) as well and and pre-sale costs fall further.  I am all in favour of taxing profits and dispensing with all taxes that stress profit-margins.  

Mr Miliband has put on the metaphorical hat he bought when supporting the policies of East Germany in his youth and decreed that electricity and gas prices will be frozen for 20 months if he becomes Prime Minister.  

Give me strength. Government dictating sale prices of any goods or services is a truly desperate policy.  Some of us are old enough to remember the prices-and-incomes policies that formed a cross-party consensus in the 1960s and 1970s.  Lest anyone does not know how it operated, by law prices and incomes could only be increased by the maximum figure dictated by government.  Yes, you read that correctly.  No matter how much the cost of imported raw products increased, that increase could not be passed on to customers if it resulted in the finished product going up in price by more than the percentage the government decreed to be acceptable, the manufacturer had to bear the cost or go bust.  No matter how much more profit a business earned in one year compared to the last, employees could not be given a pay rise greater than the percentage decreed by government.  It was utterly mad.  

Yet Mr Miliband obviously thinks it wonderful because he wants to do it again.  The first basis on which he sold it is entirely meritworthy, he claimed to want to keep energy costs down for the little people.  So say all of us, except those who supported the appalling Climate Change Act 2008 that requires the cost of energy to rise again and again.  Oh hang on a moment, the Climate Change Act was the only major piece of legislation piloted through the House of Commons by a certain Marxist Millionaire called Miliband when he was in government.  No qualms about hitting the little people in the pocket then, so what has changed?  If what has changed is that he has become an honest politician he would want to repeal all parts of his own legislation that increase cost for Mr & Mrs Ordinary, but no.  He wants to punish energy companies because they make profits.  It is no more sophisticated than that, as he admitted when giving the second reason for this proposed policy.  

He does not understand profit - he doesn't need to because he and his slimy brother inherited a fortune through careful tax avoidance and has oiled his way onto the political gravy train so there is no need for him to understand anything about anything other than his own self-interest.  

The full consequences of freezing electricity and gas prices cannot be foreseen although some things are pretty obvious.  Prices are likely to rise in advance of the freeze at least to counter 20-months of inflation, investment by the energy companies is likely to be reduced because they will have less money to invest and the pressure for crippling price rises once the freeze is lifted will be difficult to resist since 20 months of investment activity will have to be caught-up as soon as possible to try to keep the lights on. 

The Labour Party professes the desire to seek full employment.  For decades their means of seeking this has been to increase tax and create public sector jobs of little or no value.  Despite that unemployment has been higher at the end of every Labour government than at the beginning.  The only realistic chance of increasing employment is by reducing government impediments to business - both taxes that increase day-to-day overheads and taxes that reduce the funds available for investment.  You cannot expect a Millionaire Marxist to understand that, and poor Mr Miliband is no exception.  


Friday, 30 September 2011

80mph? Oh no, the planet is at risk.

The government has suggested that the national maximum speed limit might be increased from 70 mph to 80 mph in two years' time, in the interim they propose a consultation exercise. Whether the outcome will be a change in the maximum permissible speed of motorcars on our roads is pretty much irrelevant to me. I have held an unblemished driving licence for decades and will not knowingly exceed a speed limit because I want it to remain unblemished. Consider me a boring prig if you will, but I prefer to live within the law whether or not I agree with it.

Today on my way back from a hack around the golf course I heard an item on this issue on BBC Radio 5 (actually not so much of a hack, I went round in 78 gross on a par 72 course, something went wrong with my usual ineffectual sporting technique - I only throw this in because I'm very proud of it and will almost certainly never do it again).

A number of statements issued by people and organisations involved in the motoring business were read and a few people were interviewed, including a former racing driver and the current Secretary of State for Transport. Some supported the proposal, some opposed it and some said it was necessary to investigate the likely consequences before changing the law. Fair enough.

What was not fair enough was that almost all contributors, including the Secretary of State, said a relevant consideration was the effect of an increase in the maximum lawful speed of motor cars on British roads on the amount of carbon dioxide exuded into the atmosphere.

It really is quite flabbergasting that the anti-carbon dioxide religion has taken hold to such an extent that a minor change in the law of England, Wales and (I believe) Northern Ireland should be thought to have a potential impact on emissions of CO2 that can be of relevance to the well-being of our planet and/or human life on our planet.

The UK (including Scotland which is in charge of speed limits through its own so-called Parliament and is unaffected by the proposed change) produces less than 2% of all carbon dioxide spewed forth by human activity. Traffic on roads carrying a speed limit lower than 70 mph will not be affected by the proposal and not all those travelling on roads to which the national speed limit applies will drive faster and spew more CO2 as a result of the maximum permissible speed being 80 rather than 70.

Against that background it is obvious beyond doubt that any additional CO2 coming from those cars that will be driven at higher speeds because of the proposed change will be such a small amount that it can make no difference to anything. It will be a small percentage (if, indeed it even reaches 1%) of the less than 2% of world emissions coming from the UK.

You can close down all human activity in the UK and the result will not have any measurable effect on the climate. Even if we accept the very direst predictions of those who claim additional human-produced carbon dioxide will cause great changes to the climate and that those changes will be detrimental to human existence, the removal of the 2% currently produced by the UK cannot affect matters to a measurable degree because other countries (especially China and India) are increasing their emissions by far more every year.

To take a proposal that might increase the UK's emissions by a tiny amount and seek to include that effect as a consideration that should affect the decision to accept or reject the proposal is, frankly, moronic.


Thursday, 20 May 2010

The hipless 3,000 - a step in the right direction

The decision to scrap HIPs (home information packs) has caused no discernible howls of protest. There was always something fundamentally absurd about HIPs, although in one respect they were a reasonable idea.

When someone is deciding whether to buy a house or flat he will want to know various things about the property. Obviously he will need to be assured that the vendor has the right to sell it and he will need to know whether it is freehold or leasehold and, if the latter, the terms of the lease. He might also want to know something about the condition of the property and whether any recent work done to it complied with Building Regulations, but he might not. A HIP had to contain information on all these things together with a report on how "energy-efficient" the property is. Energy efficiency certificates will still be required as a matter of EU law, it is the other stuff that is no longer compulsory. Like so many elements of the interfering nanny State, failure to provide a HIP could result in a fixed penalty notice being issued to the defaulting vendor.

The problem with requiring the vendor to supply all that other information up-front is that any prospective purchaser will have to check some of it for himself anyway and might not be interested in the rest. No purchaser in his right mind will buy a property without being satisfied from his own enquiries about exactly what he is buying and that the purchaser has the right to sell it. No sane solicitor or licensed conveyancer acting for a prospective purchaser will rely on documents produced by the vendor as evidence of the right to sell, he will undertake his own search at the Land Registry - in fact this is done online and takes only moments. A conveyancer will also undertake his own searches of relevant local authority registers to ensure there is no risk to his client from such matters as threatened compulsory purchase or breaches by the existing owner of Building Regulations. Although the vendor's HIP will almost certainly tell the truth about these things, a conveyancer who does not undertake these simple searches himself would be liable to a claim from his client if a problem later emerged. Requiring the vendor to undertake these searches and disclose the results simply results in the same work being done twice.

So far as the condition of the property is concerned, a purchaser who wants to know something can ask. If the vendor refuses to answer his question he will, no doubt, walk away from the negotiation. But not all purchasers are interested in the property's condition because many plan to make changes once they move in and the current condition is pretty much irrelevant. Requiring the vendor to volunteer irrelevant information is a pure waste of time and requiring him to volunteer relevant information achieves nothing other than a possible speeding of the sale process by a day or two. In fact many conveyancers have followed the pre-HIP practice of making specific requests for information their clients want to know whether or not it was included in the HIP. They formed the view that it is better to have a specific answer to a specific question, so HIPs resulted in duplicated work again.

The one, limited, way in which HIPs are a good idea is in relation to properties with a problem (perhaps a new gas appliance was installed but not certified y a competent person or there is a proposal to build a sewage works behind the rear garden wall). It does happen that purchasers are interested in a property only to discover a problem later and back out after they have incurred time and cost; alerting them to such a sticking-point would prevent them even making an offer. Although this happens it is not common and is hardly a good reason for requiring all vendors to spend money on a HIP for fear of a fixed penalty.

It has been said by the Director General of the Association of Home Information Pack Providers (AHIPP) that 3,000 jobs will be lost and 10,000 will be affected (I presume he meant affected for the worse). I find that comment interesting in several respects.

First it is interesting that AHIPP exists at all.

Secondly, HIPs will still exist for those who want them. Any vendor who thinks it is a good idea to provide a HIP can still do so, yet AHIPP says 3,000 jobs will be lost. I infer from this that he knows most vendors will not want to provide a HIP and most potential purchasers will not be deterred by the absence of a HIP. If ever you want proof that HIPs are a piece of pointless bureaucracy, the Director General has provided it.

Thirdly, the lost jobs will be lost because they should never have been created in the first place. I have commented before on the cruelty of creating non-jobs. In that piece I discussed the public sector but the same point applies to the hipless 3,000. They entered this field of work in good faith because they were told it was important work of benefit to the country, no doubt many saw it as a stable job and a step-up from what they did before. As it is they will be out of work because there is no real demand for what they did. Time will tell what they find to do instead but I have no doubt many will end up worse off than if they had never entered the field in the first place.

Fourthly, I wonder how many ministers from the last government will condemn this as "taking money out of the economy" or will say it should not be done now because it will "threaten the recovery". Not many, I'd wager, because the jobs are in the private sector and only the State matters to them.

What I find of most interest is not the reaction of AHIPP but the fact, for fact it is, that there will be no outcry over this. Indeed there will be widespread relief that an unnecessary burden has been lifted. It is Step One on a very long walk.


Tuesday, 2 June 2009

Lead me not into ...

One of the joyous consequences of balmy weather is the evening constitutional. Today it took me on a fine ramble for over an hour, including a trip around Newington Green. Newington Green is undergoing something of a revival involving the wholesale reconstruction of the green itself to include generous lawns for picnics, children's playground and an outdoor theatre area. One of the roads feeding onto the green has been closed to provide a large al fresco dining and drinking area for the bars abutting it and the more sensible restaurants and cafes have made outdoor spaces and offer snacks and ice creams to attract passing trade. There's something of a throb about the general atmosphere on nice summer evenings.

And then there are the dogs.

In the space of ten minutes in and around the green I witnessed at least half a dozen unleashed dogs, some on pavements following cycling or walking owners, others running around on the green itself. Perhaps I hold an extreme view because I was bitten by a dog when a small boy and still bear the long scar on my flabby right thigh; although I doubt I am the only one who finds the sight of a roaming hound with slobbering chops more than a little uncomfortable.

Dog owners just don't seem to get it. Of course some consider their creatures to be akin to a handgun and use them to intimidate the meek, most do not. It is the "most" that trouble me more. Let me take you back about two years to a bright summer morning when I was having a cup of tea with a neighbour while sitting on the front steps of FatBigot Towers. Someone who lives a few doors south came along with her dog and joined us for a chat. I didn't know her from a bowl of soup but my neighbour did. Her hound jumped up at me a number of times and I asked her to restrain it. It might or might not be relevant that we were all on my property and she entered uninvited, although it might say something about her general attitude. The exact words I used were "would you mind keeping your animal away from me please?" Said, I think, without malice and phrased very much as a request rather than a command. Her response was exactly what I had encountered from dog owners before: "He's only playing, he won't hurt you."

What she meant was: (i) if it did the same to her she would consider it playful and (ii) she would not expect her dog to do her harm. She had no idea that the very act of having an animal jumping at me was harmful to me, it scared me as dogs always scare me. That she felt I should not be scared made no difference. That the dog did not, on that occasion, sink its fangs into my fleshy body made no difference to the fear because the fear lay in the risk.

A few months later her dog did bite someone. I did not witness the event but heard about it from the very same neighbour I was chatting to when it attacked me. He was an eye witness and informed me that her reaction was to blame the victim, a child of ten, for scaring the dog and she used that well-worn half-truth so beloved of animal owners "he's never done that before", as though it excuses her irresponsibility in allowing an animal to run free in public.

All dogs have the innate capacity to bite strangers, some are more inclined to do so than others but they can all do it and an awful lot achieve the feat despite the feigned astonishment of their owners when it happens.

My return from tonight's constitutional required me to cross the road twice to avoid oncoming untethered dogs; one a scrofulous collie and the other a well presented but dribbling Staffordshire bull terrier. I shouldn't have had to cross the road because the owners should have had their pets on leads but they decided to promote their opinions of their dogs above the opinions others might have. One day the law will come to its senses and allow roaming dogs to be shot on sight.


Tuesday, 19 May 2009

Speaking of incompetence ...

It was painful watching the Speaker floundering yesterday as his failure to grasp the nettle and show leadership resulted in the very public loss of personal authority over and, indeed, actual control of proceedings in the House of Commons. In just a few minutes last week he made yesterday's humiliation inevitable as he tried to shout down his critics rather than looking them in the face and answering their comments.

For the benefit of my reader overseas I should explain. As you have probably heard our MPs have been caught twisting the rules to award themselves additional income by getting the taxpayer to cover some of their ordinary living expenses. It's caused a huge stink and the Speaker, a rather thick man by the name of Michael Martin, is the person with responsibility for sorting it out. His first move was not to arrange for these claims to be reviewed and paid back but to call in the police to investigate how details were leaked. Last week one MP sought to question his decision to involve the police. The Speaker had two legitimate courses of action open to him, he could have stood by his decision and explained it or he could have admitted that he was wrong and announced that he would be inviting the police to cease their enquiries. Instead he interrupted his challenger, prevented her finishing her question and used extraordinary language to tell her, in effect, to shut up and mind her own business. Another member tried to raise the same issue and was also rebuffed rudely and disrespectfully. Unfortunately Mr Martin picked on two moderate and polite MPs thereby showing himself not just to be intemperate and rude but to be a bully as well.

Many have questioned his suitability as Speaker ever since he was appointed, in the space of just a couple of minutes everything became clear even to his supporters. Here is a man out of his personal and intellectual depth. Parliamentary chickens began to come home to roost. Yesterday he decided to make an address about the whole scandal of MPs' rampant profiteering and offered a limp apology by way of reading a short written statement over which he stumbled on a number of occasions. There was no plan to deal with the problem merely the announcement of a meeting with leaders of the various political parties. It simply didn't get anywhere near addressing the problem, it showed no leadership or initiative and gave no hope that he was capable of resolving a problem that had become a national scandal.

Following his address he was asked what was happening about a motion of no confidence in him which had recently been tabled but not yet scheduled for debate. And that is when his last shred of authority disappeared as he was unable to explain the applicable procedure. It was apparent that he had totally lost control of proceedings as members barracked him in a way not seen in living memory. Today he opened the day's proceedings with a personal statement lasting barely half a minute in which he announced that he will resign as Speaker on the 21st of June.

These events were a fine example of what personal authority entails. One might expect a Speaker of the House of Commons to be an expert in Parliamentary procedure, to have a quick mind that allows him or her to respond to points of order without disrupting debate unduly, to possess a ready wit with which to diffuse tension, to have an air of authority and to be able to represent our Parliament overseas and to visitors from overseas through intellect and charm. Mr Martin has none of these qualities. Most obviously lacking is the air of authority without which it is impossible to be an effective chair of a debate.

Personal authority is such a difficult thing to define yet nothing can be easier to recognise in real life. It is that aura that makes us automatically listen to someone and to be prepared to accept what he says, we see it in captains of sports teams and at our places of work, some people are natural leaders and others are not. Tony Blair is whereas Gordon Brown is not, indeed he is the only Prime Minister in my lifetime to lack that capacity. I think the quality is one of self-assurance as much as anything else, but it is not only self-assurance. It carries with it an invitation to follow the leader rather than a challenge to do so. It is "this is what I think and I hope you will agree" rather than "this is what I think and you must accept it". The first causes any debate to start from a presumption that the leader is correct whereas the second encourages discord and conflict.

The central lesson to be learned from Mr Martin's disastrous reign as Speaker is that picking the wrong person cannot easily be rectified. He became Speaker in October 2000 yet it took until May 2009 for the cumulative detriment of his incompetence to be so overwhelming that he had to go. In the meantime the government has steamrollered badly drafted and ill-considered legislation through Parliament with little, if any, debate and detailed policy initiatives are now launched through leaks to newspapers and speeches to special interest groups. A competent Speaker would not have allowed this to develop as it has. The recent furore over MPs' expenses was the last in a long line of issues on which Mr Martin's lack of leadership led to conventions of honourable behaviour being weakened and then abrogated entirely because there was no one to uphold them. It's all very well saying MPs and ministers should behave honourably but not all will, some try to push the boundary. That is where qualities of leadership are required in a Speaker so that he can ensure proper standards are maintained. It helps to set the whole atmosphere by which the business of the legislature is conducted and acts as a check on any governmental desire to rule by diktat rather than by reason.

So now we have reached a point at which both Parliament and the government are drifting from one crisis to another, neither is being led or managed with any degree of competence. It will take a lot more than a new Speaker to put things right, but it does need a new Speaker, one who can pick the whole thing up by the scruff of the neck and give it a good shake. That won't make the government any more competent, nothing can do that because they simply don't have able people waiting to replace the dross currently filling the cabinet. What it can achieve, however, is the reintroduction of a proper system of law making so that any further damage done in the final year of this rotten Parliament is kept to a minimum.


Thursday, 26 March 2009

Rights and irresponsibilities

A couple of days ago the government launched a discussion about what it calls "rights and responsibilities". The Green Paper in which the scope of the discussion is contained sets out the government's position clearly. They seek to establish a new Bill of Rights. There is no special magic in the words "Bill of Rights" because there is no universal legal or linguistic limitation on what a state or government can include in something it calls a Bill of Rights. It could include fundamental constitutional principles only, or it could add specific laws of a non-constitutional nature. Following the latter course merely stores up problems for later.

Constitutional principles are all about the powers of the institutions known collectively as the State. In the UK those institutions grew up in various ways over time and many of the limitations on their powers are defined solely by convention. In recent times many of the ancient conventions (some of which are not actually particularly ancient) have been ignored by governments of both parties in favour of the unsupportable "I'm in office, therefore I'll do it how I want". Margaret Thatcher was noted for riding roughshod over her cabinet when she felt their collective view was wrong and that attitude has been taken further in the Blair and Brown years by the virtual abolition of cabinet government, with decisions being taken by a small cabal of the Prime Minister's trusted advisors (not all of whom are members of the government let alone the cabinet). The relationship between the executive and the legislature has also changed beyond recognition with policy announcements being leaked to the press and then announced to the press long before they are put to Parliament. Debate of important new legislation is curtailed like never before and some very serious issues are not allowed to be debated at all.

These changes of approach could not have occurred if the powers of the Prime Minister, the cabinet, the executive as a whole and the legislature were enshrined with specificity in an overriding constitutional document. I can see a case for such a document being produced provided it is limited to defining the powers of the main institutions of the State and contains a method of enforcement. The exercise is far more easily said than done, but that does not make it impossible.

What makes me shiver in anticipation of something truly ghastly is the present government's notion of a constitutional document setting out the responsibilities of the little people to each other and to the State. At the moment we owe one duty to both each other and to the institutions of the State. We must comply with the law. Nothing else is needed and nothing else is appropriate. If I breach my neighbour's legal rights he can seek a remedy against me through the courts. If I breach the criminal law the State can prosecute me through the criminal courts. In either event I will have done the same thing, I will have failed to comply with the law.

That is not to say that we are not subject to all sorts of forces that compel us to act in particular ways even though the law does not require us to do so. Most of us try to be polite and to treat people with respect, others aren't particularly bothered and others again are rude and insensitive. How we behave in ordinary everyday situations is a product of our upbringing and our own values of what is right and wrong. It is impossible to legislate for politeness, for helping little old ladies across the road, for community bulb-planting sessions and all the other nicenesses we do to make our lives less shallow and empty than they would otherwise be. Actually, that isn't right. Legislation can be passed and we can have Community Politeness Officers stationed at every supermarket check-out to hand a fixed penalty notice to those who fails to utter a please or a thank you. In the real world, however, legislation of such a nature would swiftly bring the law into even greater disrepute than the 3,000-odd new offences created over the last decade.

Against that background we have this Green Paper discussing rights and responsibilities. Most of it is concerned with enshrining the responsibilities of the little people into some sort of advisory code. The Green Paper specifically says that the government does not propose for such a code to have the force of law, yet there are lots of lines in the document and one does not even need to read between them to see that that is exactly what they have in mind. Time and again they mention specific responsibilities, such as attending court to give evidence and reporting activity consistent with money-laundering, and assert that they are not responsibilities compelled by law, whereas they are compelled by law. They suggest the code might contain a responsibility to treat NHS staff and other public sector employees with respect. Why just public sector, why not the lady behind the bacon counter at the supermarket and the waiter who serves your bowel-burning curry? If the public sector deserves special treatment those working in it will want to receive that special treatment not just hear that people are being invited to treat them particularly well. They suggest it should contain a statement of our responsibility to protect the environment, yet different people view environmental issues in different ways - paper bag or plastic bag, which is more "green"? You might be surprised by the answer, or you might not, it rather depends how you define "green".

And then the vital question arises. What possible use is any such code unless it can be enforced? In truth there is an answer to that rhetorical question because one can look at the Highway Code and find a set of guidance about how to drive with safety and consideration that has served the country well for many years and does not, directly, have the force of law. Some of the guidance in the Highway Code reflects the law but it is failure to comply with the law that is an offence not failure to comply with the Code itself. However, failure to comply with advisory aspects of the Code can be taken into account by a court when considering whether someone was driving without due care and attention. What started out as a guide to help those who might not understand the risks involved in driving has morphed over the years into a piece of quasi-legislation.

There might seem no harm in legislation saying, in effect, "please be nice to each other" but it's hard to believe it will stop there. It must be considered against the current background of law including the catch-all law against "anti-social behaviour". At present being rude to a hospital receptionist is probably not caught by that law (although it runs the risk of you having to wait longer to be seen by a nurse or doctor). But for how long will that be the case if there is a new Responsibilities Code?

Another theme running through the Green Paper is Human Rights. It is said over and again that we now have a Human Rights Act that defines our rights but not our responsibilities. It is pointed out, correctly, that one person's right is another person's responsibility. It is then asserted, incorrectly, that because our rights are now defined so our responsibilities should be codified. That is, to my mind, an illogical leap. If I have the right to privacy it follows automatically that you do not have the right to interfere with my privacy; the responsibility is implicit in the right it is not a separate thing, they are two sides of the same coin. Create a code of responsibilities and you risk creating free-standing responsibilities without correlative rights. The more detailed the code, the greater the chance of this happening.

We have seen a worrying trend over the last decade to create broad catch-all offences that are enforceable by fixed penalty notice and are far too open to interpretation by the day-glo jacketed minor functionary with power to issue such notices. The penalties cost but the additional cost and trouble of appealing against them is far greater. It contributes to a sense of the little people being put-upon by the State, where the easy targets are made to pay while real criminals escape with a warning. A Responsibilities Code is ripe with opportunities for this pattern to be widened.

At heart I am troubled by the very concept that the responsibilities of the little people to the State are constitutional matters. They are not, they are matters for the law. True constitutional issues are concerned with the power of the State not with how the little people comply with the manifestations of that power. They operate at a different level from the laws made pursuant to those constitutional powers. The State should exercise its powers through clearly defined laws so that the little people know that engaging in those defined activities risks incurring a penalty. The laws by which the State criminalises certain activities are not constitutional laws, they are laws made using powers the constitution gives the State. Our obligation to comply with those laws is also not a constitutional matter, it is merely the necessary consequence of the laws themselves.

The greatest danger is that a supposedly constitutional document will be used to promote party-political policies for which there is not universal support. Calling them constitutional matters will seek to lift those policies out of the realm of debate and make them immutable. The most obvious example in the Green Paper is the right to medical care free at the point of delivery. That is not a constitutional issue, it is a purely political issue. It seems to be an attempt to lock us into a State-run NHS until the end of time. Maybe that is wise, but there are arguments against it which should not be shut-out from debate and, indeed, which might become more persuasive to the little people in the future than they are today.

One thing which is fairly clear is that this exercise is looking to the next general election rather than looking to make good law. The government wants to present itself as the little people's friend and will pretend that this Green Paper and any resulting legislation have that effect. It seems to me that it is a confused and potentially dangerous move which, if recent history is anything to go by, will be riddled with provisions allowing for new law by Ministerial fiat.


Tuesday, 17 February 2009

"International Commission" ... it's bound to be bad

For many years people unconcerned by hi-falutin' concepts like human rights and international courts have argued against the imposition of new criminal laws in the name of the "war on terror". It was only a matter of time before the smug intelligentsia of world crime followed suit. Lo and behold, at last the penny has dropped.

Objections to many of these so-called anti-terrorism laws come in various shapes and sizes and more than one line of criticism is often applied to a single measure. Generally speaking it is probably fair to say that the arguments against fall into one or more of four categories: (i) we already have laws that are quite adequate for the purpose, (ii) it won't have any effect on terrorism, (iii) it will be used to outlaw activities for which it was never intended and (iv) it will be used disproportionately to enforce existing minor regulatory offences.

So, we have the police given the power to stop people, search them and ask for their name and address. Something like 300,000 such stop and search incidents have occurred in the name of the war on terror and not a single arrest for a terrorism-related offence has resulted. We have laws outlawing the downloading of, for example, bomb-making instructions from the internet with the result that legitimate research and harmless seeking of knowledge are prevented. We have investigatory powers given, quite bizarrely, to local authorities who use them to enforce petty bye-laws on litter and recycling plastic bottles.

The report from the International Commission of Jurists has taken three years to research and compile and tells us nothing that has not already been analysed and commented on a thousand times. The one difference between the ICJ report and most commentaries is that we little people look at these matters in terms of what actually happens in real life whereas the big wigs of world crime are more concerned with the effect of bad national laws on airy-fairy one-world ideas such as "international human rights" and a particular aspect of "international law".

The concept of "international human rights" is one that causes my addled, flabby brain to fry. Omit "international" and I can just about understand the principle of it. There are certain things The State should not do to the little people and these are classified as "human rights" which should not be infringed save in exceptional circumstances. The problem I have with that proposition is that it is based on standards developed over hundreds of years in just a few countries and, even in those countries, the importance of the principles depends on context and on the historic and cultural values of the particular country concerned.

None of the so-called "human rights" is unqualified. Whether it be free speech, freedom of assembly, the right to a fair trial or whatever, both cultural forces and practical necessity operate to ensure there is no absolute standard. For example UK laws restricting free speech are different from those in France whose laws are different from Germany which applies different principles than the USA. Those differences result from the individual histories of the countries and the different standards applied by their law makers. Each country has to set its own standard. The French have a tradition of not disclosing the sexual peccadillos of prominent figures, whereas we tend to thrive on reading about such things. Would the world be a better place if the French learned of Mitterand's affair(s) or if we didn't know about David Mellor and Robin Cook's unlikely dalliances? Maybe, maybe not. The thing is, no one can tell because it is nothing to do with whether the world would be a better place it is all to do with cultural history and contemporary politics in each country. I defy anyone to promulgate a universally applicable principle about when disclosing prominent politicians' extra-marital affairs will be of benefit and when it will be of detriment to the world in general. Life simply isn't like that.

And so it goes with all of the so-called human rights. Take the right to a fair trial as another example. Many European countries have examining magistrates who both guide the police investigation and have to decide whether and what charges should be sent for trial. Nothing could be further from the English system in which investigation and the decision whether the evidence justifies a trial are separated. Which is right, which is wrong? The answer is that neither is right and neither is wrong because there is no single standard against which they can be judged. At the same time, each is right because each has been developed within the countries concerned and is accepted by the people of those countries as an appropriate way to do things. Does a fair trial require a jury of ordinary people or is a trial by three judges better? It all depends on what is accepted as the better system in a particular country. There are no absolutes.

We mustn't forget the right to life. Abortion, is it murder or is it not? Ask the Pope and his followers and you will get one answer, ask others and the opposite opinion will be expressed. Each country has to take a position. Whatever position it takes will meet disagreement by many of its citizens, some vociferously or even violently. That's what happens when people in civilised nations are allowed to express their views. There is never a single, once-and-for-all answer. The debate never ends on abortion and it never ends on countless other subjects which are matters of personal opinion and belief.

So, what are "International Human Rights"? The most they can ever be is an expression of hope that all countries will adopt general standards that have been developed in various ways and with various results in western democracies. Try to impose them on countries that do not have a political culture that can absorb them and you have a recipe for disaster. Try to impose them on a political culture that can absorb them but has not yet absorbed them and you are guaranteed to meet resistance. The very fact that a political culture can absorb them but has not yet absorbed them means it is taking its own time to develop principles suited to its culture and people. Any attempt to tell them to adopt certain principles into their law will be seen as a disrespectful imposition. That leaves only one option, to impose them on countries that already have them. Ah, bit of a problem there, if they already have them the imposition is pointless. And that is exactly what "International Human Rights" are, utterly pointless. Actually, I might have overstated my case there. They are not pointless if they are a point of reference for developing countries. And therein lies the problem. Therein also lies the link to my earlier point about so-called "International Law".

International law has an important part to play in international affairs. There are four aspects to international law. Much of the earth and much of the sky is not "owned" by any country. If ships are to sail and planes to fly across the bits no one owns, there have to be rules to minimise risk. The first part of international law is about movement of people and goods through non-national territory. The second part is about war. Left to its own device war is indiscriminate. With a view to trying to restrict the damage done by armed conflict, there is an international law of war. The third part is about the relation between nations. There is a body of international law about diplomatic relations. The fourth part is where the problems occur. The fourth part is all about supranational bodies and their power over sovereign nations.

The very idea that an international body should be able to dictate what a sovereign nation does or does not do is anathema to me. We have enough trouble here, a country with one of the longest histories of continues democratic rule in the world, in getting the government (of either party) to debate issues fully and pass workable laws. Having laws imposed by a body even more remote from the people than their own parliament strikes me as a bad idea.

The International Commission of Jurists seems to disagree. It is more concerned that bad national laws undermine the authority of international law than that they undermine the condition of life for the people directly affected by the offensive laws. The aspect of international law they address is the power of supranational bodies. Oh, do I see a bit of personal interest here? Do I detect the fear that countries making their own laws might undermine the authority of the International Commission of Jurists and the supranational ideas they promote?

There is an important role for international bodies to play in matters labelled "human rights", but that role is purely advisory. Any other role is, by definition, a role that bears powers of compulsion. In practice, compulsion can only be exercised against those who are playing on the same field. Only the most developed countries have sufficiently advanced social and political structures to be able to incorporate principles of so-called human rights into their law. Once those nations create supranational bodies to promote so-called human rights there is only one inevitable result. The supranational bodies will seek to justify their existence. Advising developing nations will not be enough and compelling developing nations will be impossible, the only thing left is to compel the very countries that set them up to adopt laws that those (by definition) sophisticated and developed countries have not felt it appropriate to adopt.

Just as the EU has taken on a life of its own and developed its own agenda, so all supranational bodies do the same. They might do some good at the margins, but that just encourages them to demand more powers, powers which will be exercised without democratic control and with no regard to the cultural sensibilities of the countries subject to their commands.


Monday, 16 February 2009

Freedom of speech is not a right

The other day a Dutchman with a funny shaped head wanted to speak at the House of Lords, because he had been invited to do so. Apparently he has some involvement with a film that argues the spread of radical Islam isn't the most cuddly thing in history. Indeed, as I understand his position, he says it is a recipe for repression on a scale not seen in Europe since the 1930s when an Austrian who always missed a bit shaving and an avuncular Russian with a taste for genocide both got rather overexcited.

I can't say I disagree with the general thrust of his argument. Throughout history political movements based on selective interpretations of religious texts have gained power by picking on minorities. Identifying a pariah group is an effective way of welding together others who enjoy the feeling of superiority and readily give support to the leaders who massage their frail egos. No doubt some of the leaders genuinely believe they are carrying out their god's work, but something in my ever cynical mind thinks rather more are just happy to find an excuse to wield power. Over time it would not be surprising to find some in the first category reassessing their faith but continuing to pursue the cause because power itself is hard to relinquish; equally some in the latter camp might find they become persuaded by the religious texts when previously they considered them little more than an excuse for self-aggrandisement.

Whatever the motivations of the leaders the result is the same. They gain support by telling potential followers of their superiority over the sinful minorities and then strengthen that support by using such brutal measures against dissenters that followers dare not express doubts. If you are not with them you are against them, and if you are against them your life will not be worth living. All promises of power and happiness for followers soon melt in the dust as the need to suppress dissent in order to maintain power takes precedence over everything else.

Rule by militant Islamists follows this pattern today in every country they govern. There is nothing specifically Islamic about it, it is just a universal pattern of behaviour for idealist governments. The ideal trumps everything. If democracy does not embrace the ideal, they tinker with democracy because democracy must be faulty. If ancient rights and liberties do not sit comfortably with the ideal, those rights and liberties will be trimmed because they must be faulty. If existing customs do not embrace the ideal, they will be abrogated because they must be faulty. Everything gives way to the ideal, regardless of the consequences.

One might be tempted to think that the ideal itself is immutable throughout this process, yet nothing could be further from the truth. Ideals are re-written, updated, re-defined, modernised, re-interpreted and always expanded so as to extend the power of those relying on them as their basis for power. I believe this to be inevitable because once power is taken or used in order to advance an idealist ideology the power and the ideology become self-supporting. Having power is justified because it advances the ideal and the ideal is justified by the fact that it is exercised by those in power. Any hint that the grip on power might be challenged or that the ideal can extend to areas it has not yet touched will lead to an expansion of power and a tweaking of the ideology to secure that extension. Throughout the whole exercise the justification for power is not, and cannot be, the subject of rational debate. The justification of power is a higher authority - a god, a little red book, a tome written in the British Library, or some such.

I am not sure the Dutchman with the funny shaped head objects to radical Islamism because it is the latest example of this pattern of oppressive rule, although the little I have read about him suggests he does. Objections to his presence in this country were sufficiently persuasive for hapless Jacqui the so-called Home Secretary to find a moment in her busy schedule to turn from calculating how much she get the taxpayer to pay towards her domestic bills and sign a letter informing said Dutchman that he won't be allowed into the UK. The reason given was that his presence risked inciting racial and religious hatred.

This case made me think about the distinction between idealist politics and practical politics. It is possible to look at principles such as the right to free speech as being idealist in nature and in a way they are in as much as they appeal to a general principle. The difference, as I see it, between idealist and practical politics is that the former is concerned with meeting a pre-determined, top-down edict whereas the latter is concerned with what makes life comfortable for real people living real lives and is essentially a reactive, bottom-up process. In practical politics established ways of doing things can be discarded if they no longer provide a benefit, just as the cathode ray tube has now almost disappeared from view despite being a major part in the majority of British homes for forty or more years. Other technologies have supplanted it and provide a better product, so out goes the old fat telly and in comes the slim-line model. Flat tellies did not corner the market because the manufacturers said they had to. They were offered for sale alongside their plumper rivals and took over because the little people at the bottom decided to say hello to thin.

The so-called right to free speech is very much a bottom-up concept. It is a nonsense to think of a government decreeing that everyone must speak freely, the desire to speak freely exists in us all. We all have opinions, including opinions on subjects we actually know very little about. In the absence of a legal restriction we will express our opinions, so the right to free speech reflects something that is in our nature as human beings. Of course, these days it is sometimes seen as a right given by government (or, to be more precise, Parliament) because it is contained in the Human Rights Act. And when questions arise about the use of governmental discretion to suppress free speech the debate is sometimes quite legalistic and revolves around the wording of that Act. Yet this fails to acknowledge that we all speak freely unless prevented from doing so. The law does not give us free speech, our brains and mouths do that very nicely thank you. The law can only restrict the extent to which we can speak freely without fear of sanction. It is, in my view, fundamentally wrong to talk of "the right to" free speech. It is like talking of the right to sweat or the right to chew or the right to sneeze or the right to micturate. These are not rights, they are parts of the human condition, they are things we do naturally.

Free speech can be limited on either practical or ideological grounds. Indeed in many instances the limitation is the result of both practicalities and ideology. Debate cannot operate productively unless each speaker is allowed to make his contribution without undue interruptions. If we want to hear all sides of the argument it is necessary to stop other people speaking while one contributor is having his say. The practicalities of the exercise require freedom of speech to be curtailed in order to allow each case to be put. Practicalities also require all sides to have a fair amount of time to put their case. Ideology also comes into this. We generally accept that open debate is beneficial. That is an ideological proposition, yet when analysing why we hold that ideology we get back to the simple fact that we all hold opinions and human nature dictates that we wish to express them. The ideology comes from the bottom-up not the top down, and there is no conflict between ideology and practicalities in this example.

The law of defamation is somewhat different. If our words cause harm to another we step beyond the realm of mere speech. Untrue words can ruin an individual's life and they can ruin a business. The law steps in to penalise untruths that cause significant harm for essentially the same reason it steps in to penalise physical violence, the harmful consequences are unacceptable. It is not necessary for you to know that what you say is untrue, if it is in fact untrue and it causes the necessary harm the law of defamation hold your liable (subject to certain exceptions which I needn't deal with here). The law in this field is more top-down than bottom-up because it imposes a penalty even where the guilty party is sure he has told the truth. In the field of defamation, for all the many faults with the law as it stands, the truth is always a defence.

If the law is to impose a limitation on free speech it risks being brought into disrepute unless there is a solid ground for doing so. New laws over the last decade have sought to restrict free speech like never before. There are arguable justifications for some of these laws. For example, religious beliefs are at the heart of many people's lives and to find their religion being vilified is, no doubt, a matter of great distress to them. Similarly, discriminating against people because of their pigmentation (I refuse to fall for the "race" argument, it is nothing to do with race it is all to do with pigmentation) leads to them being treated unfairly and is not acceptable in a sophisticated country like the UK. Arguing for discrimination against those of dusky hue can, therefore, be seen to be sufficiently harmful that freedom of speech should be curtailed in that respect. Yet even though burning heretics and refusing work to someone of dark pigmentation are rightly unlawful, to take the argument one stage further and prevent debate on the subject is another matter entirely. There is no more justification for preventing such debate on the ground that it might encourage some people to barbecue the local vicar, than there is for allowing the debate so that the good sense of not engaging in a clerical conflagration can be spread to the widest possible audience.

What troubles me most about the new laws, as exemplified by hapless Jacqui's letter to the Dutchman with a mop on his head, is that they are based on idealism not practicalities. The ideal in question is the new religion known as "anti-racism". It causes boxing commentators to differentiate between a large dark-skinned man and a large pink-skinned man by the colour of their shorts when the difference between their pigmentation is far more apparent. It causes the word "black" to be reserved for use as an exclusive label based on pigmentation, to such an extent that I have witnessed a senior government minister frowning at the question "black or white coffee" and answering "with milk". It causes children in need of a loving home to be refused a suitable placement because the foster/adoptive parents are of different pigmentation to the child. It causes walking on eggshells in so many fields, and all of it serving no useful purpose. And, like so many shallow and narrow ideologies, there are victims of all pigmentations scattered along the way.

But more, there is also a far wider harmful consequence to the very people this muddled new religion claims to help. It creates formal legal divisions between people of different skin colour. It also creates a government-approved sense of victimisation even where there is no justification for it. Some argue that instilling a sense of victimhood in people of dark pigmentation is a deliberate consequence of the new religion because it makes them more likely to support the politicians who label them victims. I'm not convinced of this, I believe it is more likely to be an unintended consequence of unprincipled good intentions being taken too far.

It seems pretty obvious why the Dutchman was excluded. It was not because he wished to argue against the spread of radical Islamism. It was because he wished to argue against a religious-political movement which involves almost exclusively people of non-pink pigmentation. What a curious irony it is that preventing radical Islamists from exploding themselves in the tinned fruit aisle at Sainsburys requires CCTV cameras on every street and random searches by the police, while someone who wishes to argue against radical Islamism is excluded from the country in case his speech is construed as being less than chummy to any human grenades who happen to be a bit brown.

Many have commented that this issue is an example of our current government introducing thought crime onto the statute book. They have a point. I prefer to look at the way the legislation was formulated and describe it as ill-thought crime.


Saturday, 31 January 2009

The need for discretion in law enforcement

There was a time when substance had precedent over form. The best examples I ever saw of this were in my early appearances in Magistrates' Courts as a fledgling barrister. While waiting for my tiny and inconsequential hearing to come around I would witness how things actually happened, not what a textbook said, not what an Act of Parliament said, not what might be portrayed in a television drama, but what actually happened.

Take this, for example. Mr Bloggins has been summoned to court because his car was seen on a public road without a current tax disc visible in the window. For the benefit of anyone who does not know, in the UK we have to pay an annual tax, known as vehicle excise duty, if we keep or use a car on a public road. The receipt given for this tax is a paper disc showing the registration number of our vehicle, the amount paid and the period for which we have paid. Mr Bloggins turns up with the tax disc which clearly shows it was issued prior to the date of the alleged offence. The Act of Parliament made it an offence to have a motor vehicle on the road without displaying a vehicle excise licence (tax disc). The offence was not failure to pay the tax of failure to be in possession of a tax disc, but failure to display a tax disc. If he turned up with a little circular piece of paper with perforated edges showing he had paid his road tax for the relevant period, the summons would be withdrawn. The prosecutor would explain to the court that Mr Bloggins had in fact paid the relevant tax and has the disc as evidence of that, and the magistrates would agree to the case against him being withdrawn. In almost all instances Mr Bloggins would not be required to pay any costs and would not receive an admonition for his error.

You see, anyone with any common sense will understand that failing to display a receipt for a tax is a purely technical default. Of itself it does no harm to anyone or anything. The substance of the offence lay in a failure to pay the tax even though the way the Act was worded it was failure to display the receipt which was the actual offence. Any prosecutor daft enough to seek to continue a prosecution once shown irrefutable evidence that the tax had been paid would have faced an immediate question from the bench: "what's the point of this prosecution when Mr Bloggins has paid the tax?" On being reminded of the wording of the relevant part of whatever Road Traffic Act it was, he would have been reminded that the court was interested in the substance of the thing.

The modern way is to promote form over substance, especially when it comes to many of the minor infringements of the law punishable by fixed penalty notices rather than criminal prosecution. Drop a bit of litter and there is no one to turn to when you are slapped with a £50 ticket on the spot. A court, on being satisfied by your evidence that the littering was entirely accidental and happened when you pulled your handkerchief from your pocket and unintentionally dislodged the business card of Chantelle (the quick relief therapist at Madam Fifi's Sauna and Hanky Panky Parlour), might well clear you of the accusation completely. Or, if satisfied that you were careless but not intentional in your conduct, impose a far lower penalty than £50. None of that comes into it now. No sooner have the words "let Chantelle French polish your helmet" hit the tarmac than you are down £50 and that is that.

I was thinking of this (discretion I mean, not Chantelle) a few months ago after running into an old chum who sits occasionally as an adjudicator hearing appeals against parking tickets and other fixed penalty notices issued for car-related wickednesses. He explained to me that his role is limited to looking into the strict legality of the matter and that he has no discretion. No matter how much sympathy he might have with the plight of the appellant and no matter how minor or technical the infringement was, if there was an infringement of the strict letter of the law he must uphold the penalty notice. He can only quash a notice if, for example, the signs denoting the restriction on parking did not comply with the relevant regulations or were ambiguous or misleading.

Law enforcement is an important part of setting the atmosphere in a country. There are two extreme positions which are guaranteed to lead to discontent - arbitrariness and inflexibility. Random enforcement subject to the whim of the enforcer can lead to corruption and increased lawbreaking but its greatest fault is that the people never know where they stand. Inflexibility is guaranteed to lead to seething resentment among those who believe they were treated unfairly when genuine mitigating circumstances were ignored.

A degree of arbitrariness is inevitable because those who decide how and against whom to enforce laws are human beings and exercise their own judgment. It is impractical to expect these decisions to be uniform, nonetheless the risk of wild variation can be tempered by guidelines, training and discussion between those making the decisions. Similarly a degree of inflexibility is inevitable because a standard has to be set and sometimes that means a minimum sentence for a particular offence. The task of government is to reach a sensible balance.

We are not particularly beset by arbitrary law enforcement in this country but inflexibility is becoming systemic as more and more new offences are created and made enforceable by fixed penalty tickets. Often enforcement is in the hands of low-grade employees of local councils who either are not given discretion or do not have the ability to exercise it. The risk of cash-strapped councils looking to fixed penalties as a means to raise money is a further problem. Whether they set formal targets or not, once they are reliant on receiving a certain income from that source the appearance will arise of law enforcement being a revenue-raising issue and not one concerned primarily with justice.

You can label it a loss of liberty or the erosion of freedoms, but I would suggest that the real vice behind inflexible law enforcement is that people feel they are being treated unfairly. The fixed penalties for dropping litter or breaching any of the hundreds of other regulatory offences subject to such penalties are often greater than those for minor thefts and assaults. How many people think dropping a toffee wrapper is more serious than stealing a packet of toffees? Yet it's fifty quid for the former and a written warning for the latter. The balance is wrong, and when the balance is wrong resentment builds, a sense of being put upon builds, a sense of government (local or national) bullying the essentially law abiding builds. A sense also builds of law enforcement being guided by money, targets and statistics rather than by the need to maintain the peace and protect people and property.

And this all comes from removing discretion from the process and replacing it with the soft option of strict liability.


Saturday, 20 December 2008

Libel and the loudmouths

My attention has been brought by the great Mr Leg-Iron to some recent complaints of Labour MPs about the courts upholding the law. The instance he mentioned concerns the law of defamation. Some MPs seem to believe it should only be applied in certain circumstances, I fail to see how that is a complaint about the courts rather than about the laws MPs have the power to change, but we can leave that observation to one side for the moment because I want to look at defamation more generally.

The current law is, in essence, quite simple. If you publish an untrue statement about someone he has a claim against you provided your statement is more than mere insults, it must involve a slur on his reputation. Obvious examples include allegations of theft, adultery or corruption. The thing you allege need not be a crime but it must be behaviour which people generally would consider improper. There are numerous qualifications to this general definition, particularly when it comes to spoken defamation (slander) but also in relation to written defamation (libel), but it will do for present purposes.

Personal reputation is what other people think of you. It is a rather nebulous concept which is more important to some people than to others and is certainly of great importance in some fields of work although sometimes a bad reputation can be far more lucrative than a good one. Many a lawyer or accountant with a reputation for being less than honest can pick up a lot of business precisely because their clients want someone clever and crooked to get them out of trouble. Nonetheless, the vast majority and lawyers and accountants would consider allegations of dishonesty to be potentially damaging to their careers and might feel it necessary to sue to put the record straight.

It is entirely understandable why someone might want to sue where something written about him could ruin his career but it is a dangerous path to take unless you are absolutely squeaky clean. In a well publicised case a few years ago a solicitor was accused of using confidential information for his own benefit in a commercial transaction, a very serious allegation against someone under a strict duty of confidentiality. In fact he did not use confidential information but he was competing against a client in the transaction, which is also a serious breach of his professional duties. Although what was written about him was untrue he lost the case because he had acted in breach of his professional duties albeit in a different way from that alleged against him. His high reputation was damaged but because he had acted improperly that high reputation was not justified and the false statement only lowered his reputation to where it should have been anyway. It cost him a lot of money because he had to pay the other side's legal costs as well as his own.

Another risk exemplified by that case arises from the fact that court proceedings are public and can be reported in the newspapers. The original allegation against the solicitor was made in writing to only a few people whereas the debunking of his reputation made it into all the serious newspapers and guaranteed that any harm he might suffer was magnified a thousand times. And there we face another of the great quirks of defamation law - how often does a false allegation of misbehaviour actually harm someone? It goes without saying that it will hurt their feelings and might cause some people they deal with to be reticent to put business their way, however I find it hard to believe that anything other than very serious allegations will cause more than a minor blip to any career. The solicitor I mentioned is one of the country's leading experts in a complex area of law and still sustains a large and successful practice today because he is very good at a very difficult job. There is no outward sign that the lowering of his reputation has had any lasting impact on his career. That case, like many (but not all) defamation cases, seems to provide proof of the old saying "sticks and stones may break my bones but words will never hurt me".

One of the most curious aspects of English defamation law is that it is up to the jury (where there is one, the parties can agree trial by judge alone) to decide how much should be paid by way of compensation for loss of reputation. This is separate from the question whether any financial loss resulted. Where money was actually lost the defendant will be ordered to pay that sum in compensation. In addition he will have to pay for what is, in essence, hurt feelings. While you might get £5,000 for a badly broken arm or £50,000 for losing a leg, someone who harms your reputation can be ordered to pay far more even though the defamation has not cost you a penny. Most high awards by juries appear to reflect their disapproval of the defendant's conduct much more than a genuine attempt to quantify what the defamed person has suffered. By all means give full compensation where actual financial loss can be proved, but for loss of reputation alone a limit of £2,000 would be more than adequate.

The case that troubled MPs recently concerned a Saudi businessman who was accused in a book of giving financial support to terrorists. The book was published in America (where the Constitution guarantees the right of free speech and defamation actions are rare) and the defamed person lives in Saudi Arabia. It is no surprise to find members of the current governing party complaining about the English courts applying established English law to a proven defamation occurring in England, I gave up pretending we could expect sense from them several years ago. Their specific complaint in this case, as reported by The Times, was of "libel tourism" and Soviet-style censorship, in other words that someone chose to sue in the English courts because other countries have different laws and he might not have succeeded there. It is difficult to know how accurate the report is because the reporter tells of the judge "fining" the publishers when he did not such thing - a fine is imposed for breach of the criminal law, a judge or jury in a civil defamation case can award damages but cannot impose a fine. It is also reported that the book was not sold in this country, which might well be true, but unless a defamation has occurred in this country the English court has no power to do anything about it, so there must have been some distribution of the false statement within England.

Be that as it may, the substance of what a junior minister in the Justice Department and a rent-a-quote back bencher are reported to have said is deeply worrying and tells us more about their ignorance of the law than it does about any deficiency in that law. "Libel tourism" is all about people suing in this country because our law gives them a remedy they might not get elsewhere. If MPs don't like it they have to change the law. Neither lawyers nor judges can refuse to apply the law once a case has been brought, so rather than accusing those two groups of being at fault the MPs should seek to persuade Parliament. The allegation of Soviet-style censorship is quite breathtakingly and staggeringly stupid. English libel law imposes censorship in one sense only. It has the power to prevent lies being repeated. It does not have the power to prevent the truth being repeated, however unpalatable that truth might be. Print the truth and you are fine, print lies and you risk being required to withdraw your book from sale in its current form. There is nothing in that process to justify hysterical squeals about Soviet or any other style of censorship.

How curious it is that senior members of the Labour Party want to prevent foreign victims of lies having access to our courts while also wanting to clamp down on blogs that criticise their policies. No, it's not curious at all. Just another example of a party that's been in government so long that it will say anything at any time to grab a headline or stifle debate in a desperate attempt to cling to power. There will be many more examples of this sort of contradictory loud-mouthing in the months before the general election.


Friday, 5 December 2008

Queen's Speech 2008 Part III - schizophrenia

Our government is chronically schizophrenic. We have seen this most vividly in recent weeks in its approach to banks and economic policy generally. It vilified the banks for getting themselves into trouble by lending too much money to people who were a bad risk then insisted they continue lending at 2007 levels - levels which can only be reached if you lend to bad risks. It told us that its ownership or part-ownership of banks would be at arms' length, then at the first sign of the banks doing something the government didn't like it said they must come to heel because they are beholden to the government for bailing them out. It said we must all save more money then sought to dampen the recession by encouraging us all to spend. And that particular piece of double-think turned into triple-think because their main measure to encourage spending was something which would not generally reduce prices.

In the Queen's Speech were three measures showing just how deep and dangerous governmental schizophrenia has become. They cover business, the role of Parliament and (the real corker) welfare.

"My Government is committed to helping ... businesses through difficult times." Fine words, so what is it that the government proposes to help businesses. You have to search for this but there is a plan to help the cash flow of construction companies. The details do not seem to have been published yet, so it is impossible to say whether it might work. As far as I can tell that is the only thing in all the proposed new legislation aimed at making life easier for businesses. And to show how much they understand business, they propose to allow local authorities to raise supplementary taxes on businesses. Brilliant. Helping businesses through difficult times by taxing them more. Why didn't we all think of that?

"My Government will continue to take forward proposals on constitutional renewal, including strengthening the role of Parliament ..." I sometimes think the Queen must be embarrassed by having to use meaningless terms like "constitutional renewal", she knows better than anyone that the constitution does not need renewal because it is not about to expire, it's not like a parking permit. Or is it? Many of us believe that the current government has done more damage to the flexible and pragmatic British constitution than any in modern times. Perhaps that is why they made her say "renewal", perhaps they realise the damage they have done by supplanting cabinet government and parliamentary scrutiny in favour of a small coterie of insiders who answer to no one. Somehow I doubt it.

At a time when the Prime Minister refuses to answer questions in the House of Commons, the Home Secretary knows nothing and wants to know even less, national business strategy is in the hands of a sleazy spindoctor with little on his CV other than two forced resignations for being unfit to hold office, the impending closure of much of our capacity to generate electricity is answered with the pixie dust of windmills, the government stands four-square behind a partisan and incompetent Speaker of the House and the Opposition cannot oppose without fear of arrest, are we really expected to believe that the role of Parliament will be strengthened? How can they make the Queen say these things and still sleep at night?

And then there is welfare. Their proposals here are so contradictory it is almost laughable. On the one hand they say they are going to impose sanctions against those drawing benefits who refuse to try to find work. On the other hand they are going to make it the law of the land that so-called "child poverty" will be abolished by 2020. Let's cut through the weasel words. "Child poverty" means children growing up in families whose income is less than 60% of median earnings. Median earnings are currently around £26,000 a year before income tax, so 60% is about £15,600, equivalent to something around £300 a week. So they say no child will be in a family with a weekly income of less than about £300. A fine sentiment, I support it entirely as a jolly nice thing - if it can be achieved. So everyone is to be guaranteed an income of £300 a week from work or benefits or a combination of both? Ah, no, because those who don't want to work will have their current income reduced, in many cases to well below £300 a week. You simply cannot have a minimum guaranteed income (so as to meet the poverty target) if you also have a system of financial punishment for the indolent and feckless. You can't. You might want to, but you can't do it, the two cannot exist together.

I hear you say: "don't be such a silly fat bigot, Mr FatBigot, of course it can be achieved by imposing financial penalties only on benefit income above £300 a week", but that is not their policy and nor could it be because current benefit payments are well below that level in many instances. And then I hear you say: "or they could preside over a massive recession/depression so that median income falls far below current levels". Let's hope that is not what they expect and it certainly is not their policy. For all that I complain about their incompetence and their fiscal incontinence, I have no doubt that the government genuinely wants the people of this country to get richer. It's just that they show no sign at all of knowing how to achieve that. In any event, if incomes do fall substantially so will rents which, in turn will mean the amount paid in housing benefit will fall thereby making it even more difficult for those on welfare to hit the £300 a week mark.

There are other aspects of the measure in the Queen's Speech which can also be criticised as the product of governmental schizophrenia. These three caught my eye in particular. On a more general point, the biggest problem hitting much of the economy at the moment is a lack of confidence. A government with a clear plan and an unambiguous strategy to ease and then overcome recession can do a lot to restore confidence. That is one reason the country recovered so well from the recession in the early 1990s. After the disaster of the Exchange Rate Mechanism there was a significant change of approach, presented in a clear and consistent way by a plain speaking Prime Minister and even plainer speaking Chancellor of the Exchequer. There was no double-talk, no muddle of policies pulling in all directions at once. At the moment no one can tell what the government really wants or how it aims to achieve it.


Wednesday, 3 December 2008

Queen's Speech 2008 Part I - integration

An aspect of life in Britain today is that there is increasingly only one "approved" way to live. Going fast are the days of "it takes all sorts", "each to his own" and "there's nowt as queer as folk". We are badgered not just by government but also by quangoes, charities and self-appointed pressure groups about what we eat, how we dress, how much exercise we take, how we travel, how we heat our homes and countless other things which used to be matters for adults to choose for themselves.

Part of the problem is that quangoes and pressure groups never disband voluntarily and charities now feel they have to promote a cause to justify their existence and, in particular, their government funding. They suffer from "mission creep" by which a modest and laudable task morphs into a wide-ranging campaign requiring more and more compulsion for it to be adopted by a sceptical public.

They might start with the mission to educate people about the benefits of eating more fruit and veg. It starts with leaflets and a free nibble of melon from a display at the supermarket, the education campaign is successful because people then know that fruit is jolly good stuff. Consumption increases and one might think it is job done. But no. People being people, not everyone does eat more fruit and veg. The pressure groups' conclusion is that the campaign must be stepped up, targets must be set. Five portions of fruit and veg a day appears out of nowhere as the recommended intake for everyone. There is no science behind it, some need more to maintain a healthy balance in their diet and some need less because human bodies do not all absorb vitamins and minerals in the same way and different people process fibre at different rates. For the vast majority five portions a day is grossly in excess of what they need to provide themselves with all the vegetative goodness they need, but the slogan has taken on a life of its own and must be defended to the end. It becomes an "official" guideline, "at least" is added by some rabid raffia munching bully, it turns from a guideline into a government sanctioned minimum target which must be enforced in school canteens. Where once people were being informed that fruit and veg are good for them, they are now being told they must eat lots of both, it's not a recommendation but an order. There is only one healthy way to eat, it's official.

The same process applies to so many fringe issues so beloved of our current government. Take homosexuality for example. One of Mrs Thatcher's nuttier ideas was a formal embargo on local authorities "promoting" homosexuality. I have never known what that meant in practice and certainly saw no evidence of town halls handing out pink handbags to lorry drivers and denim dungarees to the ladies knitting circle. Applying one of the finest British traits, many people who previously never even thought of matters homosexual became quite angry that a minority group was being picked on by government. Tolerance of personal tastes and foibles is something we have always been rather good at as a country and many whose tolerance was previously unspoken or even unrecognised found themselves becoming pro-homosexual rather than ambivalent. The mood changed, partly through greater exposure to the overtly homosexual in fields other than entertainment and hairdressing and partly as a reaction to a bullying law.

The current government swiftly overturned Mrs Thatcher's folly and went one step further by outlawing discrimination on the grounds of sexual orientation. One might think that would be that. The wrong had been corrected and homosexuals were given an equal footing in law with everyone else. But no. It was not enough to be fair to homosexuals there was also thought a need to be intolerant of those who had a genuine moral problem in treating homosexual behaviour as acceptable. In real life we have to accept that many people adhere to moral codes different from our own, in fact I suspect we would be hard pressed to find anyone who agrees with us on every single issue of morality.

The scriptures on which Judaism, Christianity and Islam rely all condemn homosexuality as being contrary to their god's will. In a civilised society the adherents of those religions are required to accept and abide by the laws of the country in which they live but they are not generally obliged to abandon (or pretend to abandon) their beliefs. One would expect them to be able to speak out against homosexual practices and explain why they find them objectionable whilst abiding by the law and not discriminating against homosexuals. No doubt that is something the people concerned might find very hard to do because their beliefs are important to them, nonetheless it can be done and I have no doubt a great many manage to do so. When the law goes that one step too far and seeks to act against convictions of morality rather than just actions it risks being held in contempt.

In today's Queen's Speech an interesting measure was proposed about immigration and nationality. For the first time "integration" will be a requirement for those from overseas who seek British citizenship or the right to live permanently in this country. We will have to wait to see the text of the Bill to learn what is meant by "integration". To my mind any definition must involve behaviour because no one can integrate into anything unless they do so by their behaviour. I think I can guess what the government has in mind. It knows that it is at risk of leeching votes to the British National Party in a number of marginal Parliamentary constituencies, indeed the votes in those constituencies could be the difference between Labour being returned to power or exiled to opposition. What the government has in mind is dusky-skinned immigrants of the Islamic faith.

When the country took large numbers from Uganda and Bangladesh in the 1970s many of them continued to follow the practices of their homelands. The man went out to work, the wife stayed at home and looked after the children. In that there was little difference between those families and many pasty-faced whiteys of long British heritage. The difference was in how the wife dressed and acted. Gingham frocks and M&S trousers suits didn't feature; headscarves, veils and head-to-toe black smocks with a slit for the eyes were instead the attire of choice. They did not learn English unless they had to in order to be able to buy five pound of spuds and they did not involve themselves in cultural activities outside those arranged by their local mosque. In other words they did not integrate. This caused and still causes resentment among the very sorts of people who would choose between Labour and the BNP in the voting booth.

I first encountered Bangladeshi families who followed their old customs when I lived in the East End of London as a student and for a few years after starting work. Initially it was quite a shock to my system because I had simply not seen anything like it and my first reaction was to think ill of it. Then I got to know some of my neighbours and it was clear that they were just following the customs they grew up with and which they felt were mandated by their religion. A few years later I moved into FatBigot Towers in Islington. Quite close by is an area known as Stamford Hill in Stoke Newington. Stamford Hill has a large population of Hasidic Jews. Their culture is for the man to work and the wife to stay at home. They also have traditional style of dress. The women do not integrate with the non-Hasidic locals and many of them do not speak English. I am unaware of any move at any time to require them to "integrate" before they could be considered British. They are highly law-abiding people for whom their established religion and culture are of huge importance. In that they are no different from the Bangladeshis I encountered in the East End.

Forced "integration" as a prerequisite of permanent residence or citizenship steps into the same murky territory as seeking to outlaw the expression of religious opinions opposing homosexual practices. It goes beyond requiring people to comply with the law in their doings and impinges on their cultural and religious values in a way that attacks their thoughts rather than their actions. To my mind that is just as offensive as a homosexual person being refused a job because of his sexual orientation, a person of dark pigmentation being refused a job because of his colour or a person of Romany extraction being refused a job because of his race.


Saturday, 29 November 2008

Leaky ignorance is bliss

The Damian Green affair has become more and more curious as the day has progressed. For anyone who doesn't know, Mr Green is the opposition MP arrested yesterday following his receipt of leaked documents from the Home Office which he then made public. Both the leaks themselves and his use of the leaked information occurred some time ago. There are three aspects of the affair which cause my greying eyebrows to head skywards.

Before Mr Green was arrested a number of people were informed by the police of their intention to make an arrest. It is not yet clear whether the identity of the person to be arrested was disclosed but the fact that he was a senior opposition spokesman appears to have been made known. The people informed include the Leader of the Opposition, the Mayor of London and the Speaker of the House of Commons. It later became known that the chief civil servant at the Home Office was also informed. Both the Prime Minister and the Home Secretary have given the impression that they did not know of the intention to arrest an opposition spokesman, a position supported by the police.

There is a curious contradiction in what the police did. I can understand that they might see fit to inform the Leader of the Opposition because the MP in question is a member of his party. I can also understand the Speaker being informed because the intention was not just to arrest Mr Green but also to search his offices, including his office in the House of Commons. The Speaker has overall responsibility for the conduct of business in the House and has a legitimate interest in knowing that an office in the building for which he is responsible is to be searched. But why include the Mayor? The Mayor, Boris Johnson, is a senior member of the opposition party but he has no party responsibilities. He is the chairman of the body which oversees the work of the Metropolitan police but his responsibility for that police force is secondary to that of the Home Secretary, she is the government minister with overall responsibility for all police forces in the country. It makes no sense to tell someone lower down the chain but not tell the boss.

The question arises why the police should tell anyone at all, after all if they are going to arrest Joe Ordinary they wouldn't find it necessary to tell his employer or wife they would just do it. The answer is that it is done as a matter of courtesy where the action the police propose to take would or could impact on public responsibilities and raise questions senior political leaders are likely to be required to answer. Informing politicians of an impending arrest does not involve seeking their permission or giving them an opportunity to debate the matter, it is a one-way street: "this is what we are planning to do, we inform you out of courtesy, thank you and good afternoon."

If there is one senior politician in the firing line for questions about such a politically sensitive arrest it is the Home Secretary. She has ultimate political responsibility for the way the police operate in this country and questions about the arrest of a senior opposition MP are directly within her brief. It is curious indeed that she was kept out of the loop. It is reported that her most senior civil servant was informed that an arrest was to be made, what is not known is whether the police chose to inform him rather than the Home Secretary or dealt with him because she was unavailable. Either way it should make no difference because his responsibility is to report to the head of department on something so important. No doubt we will discover over the next few days whether he took any step to tell the Home Secretary, it would be utterly bizarre if he did not. She would get to know of the arrest very shortly after it happened and, no doubt, would have a few choice words if her chief underling had kept it secret. It is hard to believe she did not learn about it within a few minutes of the police informing him. If that is so, why deny knowledge of it as she has, why not say "I was not informed personally by the police but my department was informed and that news was given to me at [insert time]"?

The second curious feature is that the police thought it necessary to arrest Mr Green. We know that a junior civil servant was arrested almost two weeks ago on suspicion of having leaked information and it is reasonable to infer that Mr Green's name came up during the investigation as the recipient of that information. He could be questioned about it without being arrested. That questioning would almost certainly have to be under caution and in the presence of appropriate legal advisers, but arrest seems a very heavy-handed step to take. Perhaps he was arrested so that the police would be entitled to search his homes and offices but he could be asked for permission for a search to take place and informed that he will be arrested if he refused permission so that a search could then be made anyway. To jump the gun by arresting first seems a peculiar way to go about things, they had no reason to believe he would adopt Enron administrative practices and have a bevy of staff on hand to shred documents at the first sniff of investigation. After all, there has been nothing secret or underhand in his use of leaked information, he has put it into the public domain in the course of legitimate political debate just as politicians of all parties have for as long as anyone can remember.

My third concern is about the acquiescence of the Speaker to a search of an MP's office. Although the BBC report I link to above says that the Speaker was informed of the police's intention to arrest an MP I have heard it said that the Serjeant at Arms was the person informed of their intention to conduct a search on Parliamentary premises and raised no objection. I find this a quite extraordinary scenario. The police have no right to search anywhere in the Palace of Westminster without the permission of the Speaker. Even a search warrant issued by a court is merely a request for permission to search if the premises are part of the Parliamentary estate. Although I did not hear the interview I have read that Tony Benn said at lunchtime that the arrest and search were a contempt of Parliament. I am not sure I would go as far as that because there can be no contempt if permission is given, to my mind the important question is why permission was given.

In the days when the Serjeant at Arms was a hairy-arsed retired Brigadier any hint that the police wanted to conduct a search would have been met with a brisk response, probably "bugger off, raise the matter formally with the Speaker and he will consult the House." Today, as the BBC reports, the response is "There is a process to be followed and that was followed." This might just be unfortunate wording but it gives the impression that the Speaker overlooked that Parliament has the right to regulate itself in every way, it is its own court. That is why there is such a thing as contempt of Parliament, it is also why MPs are immune from legal action over things said in Parliament. That does not mean that it is above the law, merely that, as the supreme law making body, it has the right to protect its position of independence from outside influences.

To search an MP's office is a highly significant act. Not only will he have confidential details of constituents and correspondence of a sensitive and private nature from those he represents, but he might also have documents concerning potential future policy (including policy affecting the police). Overriding the confidentiality of such things requires a greater justification than "There is a process to be followed and that was followed." In my view the Speaker should insist that no search is conducted unless the police can show an urgent need either because certain individual(s) are at physical risk or national security is at risk. Anything less cannot outweigh the need to maintain strict confidentiality for the working papers of MPs, no matter what we think of the MPs in question.

Some have speculated that this whole episode is a government driven attempt to silence opposition. I would not put such an approach beyond our hopeless and dishonest Prime Minister but there is no evidence of it, yet. Others have suggested it was an act of revenge against the Conservative Party by the outgoing Metropolitan Police Commissioner. Again, that is not beyond the bounds of possibility but there is no evidence of it, yet. Others still have hinted at it being an attempt by the police to undermine Parliament. This one, I think, I can safely dismiss as absurd.

The true picture will emerge in time. We will find out exactly what prompted the investigation, who took the decision to arrest Mr Green and why the Home Secretary was not informed at the same time as the others I have mentioned. With any luck politicians will close ranks and assert their right to use leaked information because those in opposition need to do it now and those in government will need to do it later.

There is one possibility no one seems to have addressed yet. As I understand it Mr Green was arrested on suspicion of two offences: (i) conspiring to commit misconduct in a public office and (ii) aiding and abetting, counselling or procuring misconduct in a public office. It seems that the only "misconduct in a public office" was that of the person who leaked information to him. Conspiracy to commit that offence would require more than just receiving leaked information, conspiracy requires a plan hatched by two or more people. Aiding and abetting an offence can happen without any positive act of encouragement but counselling and procuring both require you to do something to encourage the crime. Merely receiving leaked documents would not, I think, be an offence and their use in Parliament cannot be an offence. Taking steps to encourage leaks, paying for the information when it is offered or actively planning a method by which confidential documents will be disclosed would be in a different category. I know not whether Mr Green did any such thing and I presume he did not because the presumption of innocence is hugely important. But if he did, the case would have a rather different complexion. It would also take on a different political dimension because the question would arise whether others have done the same, including those in government.

What if it is asserted that Mr Green took active steps to encourage the disclosure of documents not in the public domain? Dare the government let the case proceed and face investigation into their own conduct when in opposition? In these times when domestic burglary gets a police caution (it was an unappealable minimum sentence of three years in the late 1980s), a getaway driver for a gang of armed robbers can get community service (five years), armed robbers themselves can get three or four years (ten if they were lucky even in 1990), is there anything to fear from investigations? Of course there is because it would end careers. If the police decide to proceed it will be interesting to see whether the Attorney General intervenes and uses her exceptional power to stop the prosecution. She would be right to do so but I hope it never gets that far.