Wednesday, 11 February 2009

385 parts per million, an encore

A few days ago I tried to get my head around the concept of 385 parts per million (here). Relating it to tangible things I can measure I calculated that it is equivalent to one drop of wine out of a 75cl bottle or a single 14-point letter "O" on a sheet of A4 paper. These are very very small proportions and, in my final substantive paragraph, I suggested that it casts doubt on the AGW Armageddon theory. As well as providing me a prime supporting role in the antipodes (here), my efforts also elicited comments from some of those who seem to have no difficulty in the concept of disaster springing from tiny increases in the already tiny quantity of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. I am not a one to dismiss an argument without careful consideration, so I thought I should weigh their views and see whether they appear to have merit.

Nice Mr O'Dwyer observed that very small quantities of cyanide and polonium-210 are fatally toxic, presumably to illustrate that it is not the quantity per se that matters but the effect that quantity has on the things it affects. A perfectly fair point, as I would always expect from Mr O'Dwyer. But we must keep apples and oranges in their respective places or we will probably be in breach of an EU fruit purity directive. I have no difficulty with the concept of a tiny pinch of cyanide being enough to render my flabby frame lifeless and fit only to be turned into soap. The reason I can accept that concept is not because I have any scientific knowledge about what cyanide is or how it works, but because Agatha Christie said so many times. Equally, I don't need to understand the science in order to accept that ingestion of any substance in sufficient quantities can be fatal. The first rule of toxicology, or so I understand, is that it's all about the dose. Even apparently harmless substances can become deadly if consumed in bulk. Take my pint of choice, Gaymer's Olde English Cider. Three pints won't touch me, four and I'm ready for a drink, after five it starts to take effect, nine's a fair evening out and fourteen are likely to reappear all over the back seat of a taxi on the way home from the Dog and Duck. Yet put a sherry glass full in a baby's bottle and you're off to the big house for a well-deserved life sentence.

I'm no scientist, but I can be reasonably sure that even the nuttiest doomsayer does not rely on toxicology for his hysteria about atmospheric carbon dioxide. The case that is put is one of physics rather than chemistry. It is said that 280 parts per million by volume was good and natural and pure, whereas 385 places us on the verge of an abyss and 500 will result in world-wide disaster. It is said that this additional minuscule quantity will kick-start an unstoppable physical chain-reaction. My first question when faced with a physical argument like this is whether I can envisage such a physical (rather than chemical) reaction. That requires me to look at the actual stuff involved, including the quantity of it.

Another commenter, Mr W, suggested I might be helped by envisaging splattering 35 litres of paint around my kitchen (here). I initially thought the relevant quantity was actually 350 litres, but he has pointed out my error so I am happy to accept it is 35. In any event it does not matter to me because I cannot envisage the effect of either 35 or 350 litres of paint being sprayed more-or-less evenly throughout the air in my kitchen. He then added that I might find it useful to think of adding 15 litres of strong dye to a 40,000 litres swimming pool (here). The problem with both these suggestions is that they give rise to exactly the conceptual difficulty I was seeking to eliminate. I do not have the faintest idea what 15 litres of dye would do to a 40,000 litre swimming pool. Not only do I not have a swimming pool of that or any other size but I have no way of assessing the visual impact 15 litres of dye would make because the whole exercise is far outside my personal experience. If he spoke of one bladder of used cider emptied in a municipal pool, it would be easier but that probably wouldn't help much either.

Interestingly, the two examples Mr W gave illustrate not only the conceptual difficulty I was trying to overcome but also the misleading nature in which the proportion 385:1,000,000 can be expressed. 35 litres of paint! Oh my ears and whiskers! That's an awful lot of paint, imagine that being thrown around my kitchen, what a horror. Strong dye in a swimming pool! Sheer vandalism and a breach of goodness knows how many health and safety edicts. They appear to be nasty things because they are suggested for use in a manner for which they are not designed. Talk of 35 litres of paint when the bare plaster walls of a room need two coats of duck-egg blue emulsion and the nastiness disappears; as it does when 15 litres of black dye are used in a fabric factory.

The reason I tried to illustrate what 385 parts per million means in real things we can actually get our heads around was to eliminate hysteria and shock. As I said the other day, by my calculations it is one drop of Rioja out of a standard bottle. To ensure no one, especially Mr W, would be offended by my refusal to spray paint the air in my kitchen with emulsion and throw a couple of buckets of black gunge into the local swimming pool during pensioners' hour; I decided to experiment using the measures I find useful. So I took 75cl of water and put it in a clear jug, then I added a drop of Rioja (wasteful I know, but it's all in the name of science) and stirred well. My eyes are particularly astute where fine wine is concerned and you know what? The addition of 385 parts per million of deep purple wine to the water was completely unnoticeable. Not the teeniest hint of purple could be seen because the quantity was just so small. No doubt it would be detectable by a finely tuned scientific instrument but in real terms, terms understandable by even the cerebrally-challenged like me, it's not 35 litres of paint or two buckets of threatening black dye; it's a tiny tiny speck, a speck so small I cannot even see it when it is mixed into the bulk.

And in all this we must bear in mind that it is not the 35 litres of paint, the 15 litres of dye or the drop of fermented Tempranillo grapes that is the threat. We know this because 280 parts per million is good and wholesome, it is natural and pure and untouched by filthy human hand. Only when we get above that arbitrary, once in a world-time, number are problems said to arise. Assuming we blame naughty people for the whole of the next 105 parts per million (which, as I understand it, is not the position anyway); we find that the air in my kitchen is permeated by 25.6 litres of paint that is fine and good and only about 10 litres need to be added to represent human wickedness. We also find that the pristine swimming pool is already enjoying the benefit of 11 litres of black dye and suffering nothing but pleasure, all we have done is add 4 more. My jug of water already has almost two-third of a drop of Rioja in it and the result is unquestionably wonderful because it was added by Bacchus and not by me, only the remainder of the drop is tainted.

When asking what 385 parts per million is, I find it useful to equate it to quantities I can actually understand by relating them to real life - hence one drop of wine out of a bottle of wine and a 14-point letter "O" on a sheet of A4. Then, when asking how this tiny quantity, and/or an increase of up to one-third in this tiny quantity, can cause a physical reaction of unimaginable nastiness I find I need more than a little persuasion. That is not to say the AGW Armageddon theory is necessary bunkum, but it helps to explain why I find it unconvincing.

Addendum
Mr W left another very helpful comment (here). He questioned my Rioja and water experiment because only a small part of the wine has a colouring effect. That, of course, is true and might mean I wasted a whole drop for absolutely no benefit whatsoever. Nonetheless, my central point remains undisturbed, namely that 385 parts per million is a tiny weeny proportion of the whole and that trying to make it sound a lot is potentially misleading. Whether it is one drop of Rioja or eight drops of water, out of the total volume of a wine bottle it is minuscule.

How we little people approach a subject on which we have no technical knowledge is almost bound to be affected by how the subject is presented to us. In an area where radical politics and science overlap it is particularly important, in my view, to put things in terms the little people can understand. Tell people that humans release so-many giga-tonnes of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere each year and it sounds a daunting quantity, it is quite natural for people to consider that worrying and potentially dangerous because it can seem such a vast quantity that we infer it must cause a massive shift in the balance of the atmosphere as a whole. Tell them that the total volume of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere is equivalent to roughly one-twentieth of a level teaspoon in a volume of one pint and they might look at it differently. Then tell them that current annual human-induced emissions are equivalent in volume to just a few percent of that one-twentieth of a teaspoon and the whole game changes. Suddenly our emissions are so extraordinarily small that it is hard to see why there is any fuss at all.

Perhaps it is no more fair to play down emissions by reference to a tiny proportion of a small everyday measure of volume than it is to hype them by reference to incomprehensibly large multiples of big everyday measures of weight. If, in fact, they are causing a major problem it matters not that they are a small percentage by volume. However, for so long as the supposed problem is measured in parts per million by volume I think it is relevant to have a comprehensible reference point for the measurements because the little people still have the final say (at least in theory).


Tuesday, 10 February 2009

European corruption of law

One of the worst aspects of both the Human Rights Act and European law generally is that they encourage disreputable behaviour. Much European law consists of vague statements of principle that are concerned with ideals rather than practicalities and in doing so leaves scope for spurious claims by those keen to bask in the bright sunshine of victimhood or who see the chance to enrich themselves with an unearned buck. It might just be that I am too deeply immersed in the English common law to understand the European way of doing things, but I am not so immersed as to be unable to see a style of law that is more concerned with political gestures than with freely agreed individual relationships.

In The Times today my eye was caught by the report of a claim based on an EU political diktat. It is not so much the particular law that interested me, but the fact that the claim was made by a retired part-time judge. There are lots of part-time judges in this country. Some are practising or retired barristers and solicitors who sit for a few weeks each year for a fixed fee per day and some do it as their job. This particular case concerned a practising barrister who sat part-time until he reached the compulsory age at which part-time judges must retire, 65. When he was appointed there was no scheme for part-time judges to be paid a judicial pension, unlike full-time judges who are paid an annual salary and are entitled to a pension calculated by reference to the number of years they served. Despite there being no scheme in place when he was appointed, and despite there being no scheme in place when he retired, and despite there being no scheme in place now, his claim was that he was entitled to benefit from a principle of European law that part-time workers should have the same rights as full-time workers. Because full-time judges have a right to a pension, he argued, so he should have a judicial pension calculated according to the time he served as a part-time judge. For reasons I need not go into his claim failed on both procedural and substantive grounds (the full judgment is reported here).

What I find utterly astonishing is that such a claim would be made at all. This was not a poor downtrodden serf being forced to take on a thankless menial task for peanuts to avoid starvation and being treated like dirt by a manipulative employer. The man was a barrister with many years of successful practice behind him who applied for a part-time judicial post because he wanted to, in full knowledge that he was being offered a daily fee and not a bean more. As the Court of Appeal's judgment discloses, he is not the only one who has made such a claim. I could, perhaps, understand a test case being brought by the barristers' and solicitors' professional organisations so that the law could be clarified, but for an individual to make a claim strikes me as thoroughly dishonourable. If you enter into an arrangement with full knowledge of what it involves and voluntarily accept the limits to the financial benefit you will receive it would require a lot to persuade me that it can be right for you to turn around later and claim more.

There have been many examples under the Human Rights Act of people seeking to escape from obligations voluntarily entered into. I find it a very troubling consequence of so many laws emanating from Europe that old-fashioned straight-dealing can be undermined in this way. Perhaps I am influenced by my great interest in contract law which puts emphasis on people sticking to the bargain they have made even if it turns out to be a bad bargain. However, to me that is not just at the core of the law of contract, it is at the core of civilised behaviour. People we deal with rely on us to be true to our word and we rely on them. It allows us all to organise our lives in reasonable expectation that we will be treated in a predictable way.

Much of the debate about the EU revolves around the inability of the democratic process to affect decisions taken in Brussels. That is something about which I write rarely, although it is a matter of huge importance. But it is not only in the democratic deficit that I find the EU a dangerous entity. Once it has spewed forth its latest broad statement of political ideal coupled to a requirement to apply it throughout the EU countries, we find existing arrangements which have operated well and fairly for decades being challenged by (and sometimes overturned in favour of) those who knew exactly what they bargained for when they entered into those arrangements. The mere fact that EU law operates in a way that allows such challenges undermines reliance between people, it requires us always to look up to the almighty power in Brussels for approval of what we have agreed is a good and fair deal for us.

As someone who believes the most stable and civilised society is one reliant on trust and cooperation between individuals, I have a dislike and a distrust for unanswerable and over-powerful government. The case I have discussed here is a good illustration of how untested ideals dictated by an unanswerable government can undermine trust between people by giving an opportunity to break agreements in the name of that ideal. When ideals trump deals we are only a short step from dictatorship.


Sunday, 8 February 2009

Hapless Jacqui performs a public service at last

One of the most important aspects of the rule of law is that we are all entitled to use the law to our best advantage. The most obvious example of this is probably tax law in which there is a clear difference between minimising your tax liability by taking advantages of exemptions allowed by law (known as tax avoidance) and simply fiddling the figures thereby not paying tax that is due by law (tax evasion). Arguments surface from time to time whether it is morally reprehensible to take advantage of so-called "loopholes", and predictable positions are taken according to political belief. Those who believe in big government see it as a disgrace that government should be deprived of a single penny it might otherwise receive, those who believe in the rule of law say any objection to avoidance must be addressed by changing the law to remove the loophole.

There has long been a fine irony thrown up by such a debate. Those who argue against avoidance generally use the technicalities of the law to their advantage and the advantage of causes they support in all fields other than tax, and those who say "if you don't like it, change the law" are often first in line to tut-tut at alleged criminals escaping conviction by relying on the Human Rights Act or technical "loopholes" in the laws under which they are prosecuted.

Of particular interest to me are the more radical elements of the left who know every rule book of every organisation they wish to infiltrate and take systematic advantage of the rules to get their way. Somehow their hypocrisy over tax avoidance is particularly stark because they fight hardest to use "loopholes" to their benefit and argue loudest against others doing the same.

Apparently an advertising leaflet used by the government to attract the most politically-correct to fill specious non-jobs also prints editorial opinions and is campaigning against companies avoiding tax despite doing exactly the same itself. It is a fine example of the absurdity that arises when there is no principle behind a so-called point of principle. What possible objection can there be to individuals or companies only paying the amount of tax the law requires them to pay? I can't see one. Any who think they themselves should pay more tax can make additional voluntary payments or pay a lump sum to a charity of their choice in order to both assuage their consciences and be seen to be practising what they preach.

There is only one point of principle here, that everyone is bound by the law. Either we have defined laws or we have arbitrary rules applied according to the whim of public officials. We have chosen the former course for very good reason. If you want to argue for the latter option, by all means do so but be ready to be a victim of it yourself when the government of the day is no longer your government of choice.

We see similar lines of argument arising over MPs' expenses, in particular their right to claim certain housing costs. Today the hapless Home Secretary is exposed as taking fat financial advantage of laxly defined rules. Despite her utter unsuitability for the high office she holds, hapless Jacqui Smith is unlikely to be so stupid as to have broken the rules, time will tell. My addled brain wonders whether there is a difference in principle between what she has done and what a lawful tax-avoider does. Assuming she has kept within the rules, each has used the current law to their personal advantage and in doing so has affected the size of the Treasury's black hole. But maybe there is a difference.

When asking how much we should take from our pockets and give to poor Gordon, the natural starting point is that what we have received belongs to us unless the law says otherwise. From that starting point, a close investigation of the immensely complex web of tax legislation and regulations can be undertaken to see exactly how much we are obliged to hand over. In the absence of a legal obligation to pay poor Gordon, our position stays as it was, namely that our money remains our money. In a way it is no different from going to the butcher and asking the price of a pound of chuck steak, he defines how much it costs and we pay that much. Tax law is just a very complex price list.

When it comes to MP's expenses the position is different in one respect. Their expenses fall into two categories. There are genuine expenses such as stationery and telephone costs where the MP has to write letters and make calls in order to do his job properly and the costs of doing so are just like the expenses any employed person might incur in the performance of their job. Some have to write more letters and make more calls than others and it would be unfair if it had to come out of the basic salary. The murky side of things arises in relation to allowances. As I understand it these are sums which MPs may spend if they wish but which they are under no obligation to spend. Top of the murk parade is the second home allowance. Those whose constituencies are not within very very easy commuting distance to London may claim the cost of a second home, up to a maximum annual figure. We can debate whether an MP for a constituency in, say, Hampshire really needs a London home when the train service is so good they can get door-to-door in less time than it takes by car to cover ten miles in the London rush hour, but that is not the point of this piece.

The allowance exists and it is up to each MP to decide whether to use it and, if so, to what extent. In this respect it is different from tax avoidance. Tax avoidance is about people investigating how much (more accurately, how little) they are obliged by law to pay from their own pocket. MPs' second home allowances are about how much the MP requires the taxpayer to pay. In other words, one is about spending your own money and the other is about spending other people's money. If there is one lesson to be learned from the universally bankrupt religion of socialism, it is that nothing is easier than spending other people's money.

There is no legal obligation on any MP to claim the maximum possible sum for their additional housing requirements. Sadly examples are legion, from both political parties, of MPs doing exactly that. The Home Secretary's position is particularly bizarre and, on the face of it, dishonourable. She lives with her sister when in London but has a house in her constituency. Her husband and children live in the constituency home and by any normal definition that house is her first home. Assume you ran into her on holiday and don't know who she is. You get chatting over a glass of lentil juice and she tells you of her happy marriage, her two delightful children and her busy life as a civil servant which requires her to stay with her sister in London during the week. You ask where her home is, what would you expect her to say? Her sister's place or the house she and her husband own and where he and their children live permanently? There's no contest. She lodges with her sister and lives in her constituency. Yet she nominates her sister's house as her first home for the purpose of raking in taxpayers' cash and says her own house is her second home. That way she can claim up to £24,000 a year for her own house (an allowance she has, apparently, claimed in full some years).

Both hapless Jacqui and the careful taxpayer are using the relevant law and regulations to their benefit. The crucial difference is that the taxpayer is not asking anyone else to pay him anything and he has no control over how the law and regulations apply, he just arranges his affairs so that he loses as little money as possible. Hapless Jacqui, on the other hand, has to pay for her house anyway because her family live there and she needs a base in her constituency. She could, if she had concern for the public purse and were not just out to get as much as she can for herself, charge just the cost to her of living with her sister. Somehow I doubt she pays her sister anything like £24,000 for her room and use of the facilities; whatever she does pay is the true additional cost to her of the second home she needs in London in order to carry out her work as an MP. She has the choice of charging her employer, the taxpayer, the true additional cost (just as real expenses are charged in the real world) or pretending her own house is a second home in order to get us all to pay her mortgage and other costs for her real home.

You can forget any moral duty to pay more tax than the law requires, that is just fantasy. But when MPs have to choose between homes for the purpose of claiming an allowance there is a clear moral duty to impose the lowest possible burden on the taxpayer, to do otherwise results in the taxpayer paying for housing costs the rest of us have to bear out of our income.

There is, it seems to me, a simple mechanism to prevent this sort of dishonourable conduct. When an MP is elected for the first time he or she should have three months (or six, or nine, it matters little) in which to find themselves a base in London if they need one. In their first year they can claim for the reasonable cost of equipping that property up to the current financial limit of the allowance. At the end of their second year in Parliament, and at the end of every year thereafter no matter how long they are an MP, they must declare the costs each year of both their constituency property and their London property. The allowance will be paid equivalent to the costs of the cheaper of the two, subject to an upper limit. Not only will this help the more simple-minded like hapless Jacqui to behave themselves, it will also be a constant reminder that expense accounts are for the purpose of reimbursement of work-related expenses not personal profit.

It is very kind of hapless Jacqui to bring the current disgraceful state of affairs to public notice, at last she's done something useful.


Saturday, 7 February 2009

Here are your conclusions, now go and investigate

Well well, what a surprise. The government is going to launch an "independent" investigation into how banks are managed, so the BBC tells us. There seem to be no plans to look into how haulage companies are managed, or estate agents, or clothing manufacturers, or fish and chip shops or saunas & hanky-panky parlours. Just banks. Why? And why now?

Investigating how certain businesses are run is a perfectly legitimate role of government. There have been many such investigations over the years and for many different reasons. Perhaps there is a suspicion that a cartel is operating and keeping prices artificially high to the detriment of the consumer, or that company law regulations are being breached or taxes being evaded; all sorts of potential wrongdoing can justify an investigation. The common theme always is a concept known as "the public interest".

That term is used in various different contexts to mean different things. In relation to business it covers three things: law-breaking, unfair trading and business practices which cause structural problems to the economy.

Although it is not widely known, the Companies Court has the power to order the winding-up of a business for acting against the public interest. It is a power used to protect the public from cheats and spivs who appear to be running legitimate businesses but are in fact misleading or manipulating people in a dishonest or otherwise unfair way. I recall it being used a few years ago to wind up a company that appeared to be offering a roadside recovery service but had no trucks or contracts to use trucks and, on close examination, the contract gave the company an absolute discretion whether to send out a recovery vehicle at all. It wasn't a fraud because the contract was clear (at least to a lawyer), but it was misleading and the whole operation appeared more geared to refusing assistance than giving it, so the court wound it up to protect the public.

Applications to the court in such cases are made by the Department of Trade (or Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform as it is now so absurdly named) in its capacity as a regulator of good business practices. To my mind that is an important function which, perhaps, could be carried out by a non-governmental body, but I have no objection to it being done by a government department provided they keep politics out of it. The reason they must keep politics out of it is that investigatory powers and powers to take action against those who appear to be misbehaving are powers of law enforcement not law-making. Enforcing the law, in a fair society, should be impartial and aplotical. For decades they have had no difficulty keeping politics out of it because governments of both parties have accepted this basic point.

One aspect of aplotical impartiality is that investigations launched by government departments into particular businesses have been concerned primarily with seeing whether existing laws have been complied with. Government has no legitimate function in assessing the efficiency of individual private businesses, that is for the directors and shareholders to consider. So what is this new investigation going to look at?

The report suggests one area is "the extent to which financial incentives encourage bankers to take risks". Call me simple if you will, but I fail to see how any useful conclusion can be reached about the effect of financial incentives (ie bonuses) generally by looking only at one type of business. Nor can you discover anything by looking at specific transactions that you cannot already infer by applying a bit of common sense. You don't need to investigate anything to be able to infer that bonuses payable on the current paper value of business you write will cause people to try to maximise the amount of business they do unless there are countermeasures operating against that incentive.

Any individual banker faced with a decision whether to lend or not lend will be influenced by the desires of his employer. These are contained in formal documents outlining lending criteria: "thou shalt not lend more than 75% of the value of the property offered as security, thou shalt not accept a valuation except from a surveyor holding the qualification of Membership or Fellowship of the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, though shalt not accept proof of the income of a self-employed applicant other than ..." and so on. If these criteria are sound then the total value of business written doesn't matter and no incentive by way of bonus can do anything other than result in increased good business. On the other hand, if the criteria are too lax and leave the bank open to risk, bad business will be done and incentives to increase the amount will also result in an increased amount of bad business.

There. That's the investigation done for them. My invoice is in the post.

Bonuses do not and cannot define the quality of business done although they can influence the quantity. If a bank does not have sound lending criteria it will make bad loans. The relevant question is not what effect bonus structures have, it is what role the regulator should play in circumscribing lending criteria. There is a public interest here, namely the benefit to the whole economy from having a stable financial system. It is, therefore, legitimate for government to investigate causes of instability. What is not legitimate is to hone-in on one of the two forces governing the amount of lending undertaken while leaving the other out of account. In other words, an investigation into the management of banks is so far wide of the mark it will be a waste of time and vast sums of taxpayers' finest.

It has already been made clear what conclusion the government expects the "independent" investigators to reach. It is set out in terms by Mr Darling in his remarks quoted in the BBC article. He is reported as having said "people feel angry about excesses of bank bonuses". There we have it, the conclusion has already been reached, banks have been paying excessive bonuses. Game set and match, thank you and good evening. That is not to say I do not believe bonuses to have been excessive. My belief is that they have been obscene because they have resulted from doing bad business rather than good business and, as far as I am aware, they are not liable to be recouped when risky loans turn sour. That is absurd and, I suspect, is in part the result of bankers believing the government's constant assurances for the best part of a decade that the economy was on a path of irreversible real growth and nothing would turn sour again. More fool them.

If there is to be a formal investigation into what went wrong it must cover all relevant factors. The way banks were managed is only a small part of the picture but it is the one from which the government thinks it can gain the most political capital. Why has it not been announced that there is to be an investigation into false claims that boom and bust have been abolished, or into the failure of regulation of lending criteria, or into Credit Default Swaps and the other ways in which risk was passed back-and-forth and multiplied? It's obvious, because there is no possible chance of gaining votes from the result of the investigation.

What has been announced has nothing to do with the public interest. It is pure party politics and, as such, is an abuse of power.


Thursday, 5 February 2009

Bank bonuses and the Royal Albert Hall

All sorts of people are getting very excited about bonuses. Whether here or in the USA if there is a hint of a bank employee's current contract including a bonus structure bile is spewed like never before. How dare they pay bonuses? It's an outrage! Send in the dogs!

Now take a deep breath and ask yourself two question: (1) should a company honour existing contracts with its employees and (2) how would you draft new employee contracts to incentivise your staff?

All existing contracts containing bonus clauses have to be honoured. It is as simple as that. You can bleat all you want about how those terms should never have been agreed, but if they have they must be met.

Well-drafted new contracts have to reflect the needs of the company as well as providing a proper wage for the job in order to ensure you secure the services of necessary staff. A business that is going through a hard time and has to reduce losses or limit future losses might think it appropriate to pay a basic salary combined with a bonus scheme that pays an additional sum if losses are reduced or restricted to a predefined level. It might or might not work. Maybe the employees will have no effect and the level of losses in the year will be what they would have been regardless of what the staff did. But maybe their efforts do result in a diminution of losses, in which case they have provided a benefit far in excess of any bonus they are paid. No one can tell for sure whether such a bonus scheme will achieve anything but it might, and the job of management is to decide whether it is sensible to take that gamble in the long-term interests of the company.

There is nothing inherently unfair or corrupt in companies paying bonuses to staff in accordance with predetermined criteria. It might, in individual cases, be a bad move because circumstances can change and the bonuses might prove to be disproportionately expensive for the business. For example, a bonus calculated by reference to turnover will be payable if the defined turnover is met regardless of whether costs have increased to such an extent that the additional turnover produces no additional profit. On the other hand, a bonus calculated by reference to turnover will not have to be increased simply because the additional turnover produces more profit than anticipated.

If you choose to pay bonuses in addition to a basic salary you take a chance on those bonuses being affordable. Maybe they will be and maybe they won't, that's the gamble you take by following that path. In most instances the alternative is to pay a higher basic salary with no bonus. You are then obliged to pay the full salary regardless of how well your business does. Maybe it will be better for your balance sheet to pay people a fixed sum of £25,000 rather than £20,000 with the chance of a bonus of up to £7,500, maybe it won't. You have to decide what will work best for your business.

Objecting to bonuses simply because they are bonuses makes no sense at all. Because financial institutions were noted for paying huge bonuses during poor Gordon's boom of doom, there has developed a school of thought that bonuses are somehow inherently evil. It is utter nonsense. Indeed it is such utter nonsense that it is even more nonsensical than those bonus schemes which paid massive amounts on the assumption that all business written would be profitable in the long term. But you cannot reverse time. Stupid decisions were stupid decision, they were taken and have been acted upon. Move on and learn from the mistake.

Objecting to bonuses simply because they are being paid in the financial services industry is equally absurd. They are also paid in numerous other types of business up and down the country and at every level of employee. It is for each business to decide for itself whether to have a bonus structure, and if so what it should be.

More interesting is why people think it is their business to comment on the staff pay arrangements of financial services businesses when they would not presume to offer an opinion on the bonuses payable to Mrs Char, the cleaner and tea-lady at Madam Fifi's Sauna and Hanky-Panky Parlour. Some of the comment is just general observation about the way big businesses operate. Fair enough, that's all fine sport. But much more is comment based on the false belief that it is now the direct business of the commentator. That is what nationalisation and part-nationalisation of businesses does in a developed political system. It gives taxpayers the belief that they are now part of that business and that their opinion is necessarily valid. This belief is encouraged by misleading terms such as "public ownership" (when effective ownership is not with the public but with government ministers), it is also reinforced by the company in question becoming part of the political landscape rather than being just a business.

Of course, once something becomes a political football new forces operate. No longer are business decisions required to be taken on business grounds, now they have to be taken according to the political mood of the time. Are there votes for the governing party in a nationalised industry doing X rather than Y? If so, you find it is encouraged and, if necessary, coerced into doing X regardless of how good X is for the business itself. This influence is all the stronger in the run-up to a general election when the governing party is behind in the opinion polls.

You would have to search far and wide, and then abandon your search, if looking for a government politician who will say "They have to pay these bonuses because they have contractual commitments to do so." Yet that statement sums the position up in the shell of a nut. Where the top tier of bank employees has a contractual right to receive bonuses because their contracts were drafted when poor Gordon's boom of doom was in full swing, political bullying has the potential to force them to forgo their unmerited additional payments. And the difference it will make to the bank will be less than a gnat's fart in the Royal Albert Hall.


Don't take this, it will do you good

My attention has been brought by Mr Englishman to a most frightening individual by the name of Dr Alan Maryon-Davis. In an article on the BBC website this double-barrelled poltroon urges greater and greater intrusion by the law into what we may put into our bodies and where we may do it. His pompous, authoritarian attitude has been addressed by several commentators already including (do not read these if you are offended by strong language) Mr Smoker (here) and Mr Kitchen (here).

I have a good friend who is a doctor, a senior and well-respected consultant. He wants to ban anything that is potentially bad for people unless he enjoys doing it himself. To him, restrictions on booze are an oppressive and unnecessary interference with personal freedom and ancient social habits, whereas hunting and boxing should be banned forever and infringement punished with heavy sentences. Smoking should be permitted in the home, because he sometimes takes a ciggy, but it should be banned in pubs and restaurants because he prefers a smoke free atmosphere in such places. There is nothing fair, balanced or objective in the position he takes and he couldn't care less whether others would find their enjoyment of life restricted or lose their jobs.

It is not for me to say whether Dr Double-Barrelled is as shallow and irrationally selfish in his authoritarianism as my friend, so I will give him the benefit of the doubt and assume he really believes what he says. In order to assess the full horror of his attitude it is necessary to look at what he argues for and the reasons he gives. I have linked to the article above so I won't copy it, I think a fair summary is as follows: (1) the little people want government to manage their lives to protect them from themselves, (2) the little people are happy with the things government has already done to protect them from self-harm, (3) some of the harm the little people do to themselves it actually done by big business manipulating their feeble minds into thinking they want some thing they don't, (4) the government has done what it has done because the little people wanted them to and (5) the little people should suggest more and more ways in which the government can protect them from themselves. I have tried not to slant this summary, I think it is a fair synopsis of his article.

In this field, as in so many, blinkered thinking can have undesirable consequences. Underlying everything he says are two assumptions, both entirely without foundation. The first is that we little people are inherently self-destructive and must be protected from ourselves. The second is that the government has merely reflected public desire to be protected from themselves. Both propositions are so obviously and fundamentally absurd that one is forced to question why he has put them forward. I'll say a few things about the assumptions and then take a stab at his motivation.

Take the first assumption, that we are inherently self-destructive. That assumption is made clear in his argument that measures such as making the wearing of seat belts compulsory and banning smoking in places of work and entertainment were introduced to protect us from ourselves. By definition he is saying that without these measures we would happily keep running a merry path over the edge of a cliff. He implicitly rejects the notion that we know we are taking a risk and have voluntarily accepted that risk because we also perceive a benefit and, for us, the benefit outweighs the risk.

Every time I travel in a car, fly in an aeroplane, eat anything, drink anything, walk anywhere or, if it comes to it, do anything at all, there is a risk involved. If I travel in my car I know how it has been maintained, if I travel in someone else's I don't. If I fly with Virgin or Continental I take less of a risk than if I fly with an airline that has a less than impeccable safety record, but I might have to pay more. If I eat something I have cooked I know how it has been prepared, if I eat what someone else has cooked I don't. And so it goes on. We always balance the benefit we think we will receive against the risk we think we are taking.

The role of government is to protect us from dangers posed by others and over which we have no control ourselves and to inform us of risks we might not be able to assess for ourselves because we have insufficient knowledge. One aspect of this is legislation to seek to ensure that services provided to others are reasonably safe. For example we have stringent laws about food preparation by commercial caterers. One reason for these laws is, of course, to try to minimise the risk of food poisoning, but that is not the only reason. Hotels, restaurants and cafes are a significant part of our economy and they can only be a significant part of the economy if people have trust in their food being safe. Provided we trust them to play by the rules, we perceive little risk in giving them our custom. Some we don't trust because we have seen cockroaches nibbling at the salad bar and heard the scurrying sound of rats in the kitchen; we will give them a wide berth. Others we do not know whether to trust and the laws about food preparation help to give us reassurance.

Activities such as smoking cigarettes and drinking booze are not normally undertaken in order to shorten our lives. They are undertaken because, for those who like those things, they improve the quality of life. We can debate, until the cows stop mooing, whether there is any objective benefit from the inhalation of smoke created by burning dried tobacco leaves or from drinking alcohol, but that is not the issue. I do not smoke and drink as part of an objective exercise of living the perfect life. I do so because those activities give me pleasure. They might not give you pleasure, that's fine, you won't do them and will seek your pleasure in other ways. Like all smokers and drinkers (other than those who have been wholly isolated from newspapers, television and radio for the last thirty years) I am aware that smoking and drinking are activities with a potential downside. No doubt I have witnessed part of that downside already, having suffered a serious heart attack at an unusually early age. I continue to smoke and drink because I place the subjective benefit I receive above the potential peril I risk.

The crucial question is the extent to which government should decide what risks the little people should be allowed to take. There is a massive gulf between government advising us of risks we might not appreciate and government preventing us from taking those risks once we have been alerted to them. Advising us and leaving us to decide is the position of a government that trusts the people and knows its authority comes from the people. Preventing us from taking risks to which we have been alerted is the position of a government that does not trust the people and believes its authority exists independently of the people.

None of this has anything to do with activities which harm third parties to a sufficient degree that the law should step in to protect the innocent because that situation is outside Dr Double-Barrelled's first assumption. His first assumption is that we little people wish to harm ourselves. We don't. We weigh risks. I have described it as a balance between potential harm and potential benefit, but it can equally well be put as a balance between two types of harm. We balance our assessment of the risk of being caused harm by undertaking a particular activity against our assessment of the harm of forgoing that activity.

Take a simple example. Mr Ordinary has worked all week at the job he doesn't enjoy very much and wants to spend his small amount of "treat" money on something to give him pleasure. If he finds pleasure it balances his week, if he doesn't it adds to his overall tally of misery. His particular pleasure is eight pints of lager and a chicken vindaloo in the company of his friends. He knows that if he meets Fred, Bob and Charlie at the Stoat and Scrotum for five pints and they then visit Curry Heaven for a chicken vindaloo and three more pints, he will go home a very happy man. It will make his week and prepare him for the next. You can isolate the eight pints and say that is a harmful amount to drink in one night. Maybe it is, maybe it isn't, that doesn't matter one jot. You can isolate the burning hot curry and say it is bad for his digestive tract and bowel movement. Maybe it is, maybe it isn't, that doesn't matter one jot. What matters is that it is what he enjoys doing and, if you want it in quasi-medical terms, that will be better for him than drinking tap water with a meal of tofu nut-roast surprise. It will be better for him because life is about more than the body, it is also about the mind and emotion and happiness.

People like Dr Double-Barrelled seem to have no comprehension that dying at fifty as a result of the things that have given you a happy life is, for those who choose that life, better than dying at eighty-five after a lifetime of pious abstinence. He clearly believes that smoking and drinking a lot are harmful, but he only looks at one side of the equation. The other side of the equation is the subjective quality of life of the individual concerned. He cannot measure that, and no amount of self-righteous bleating by pompous prigs like him can change the fact that real people take decisions based on how they value the things he wants to ban.

This missive is already long, so I will deal with his second assumption quickly, it is that the government has legislated to reflect a public desire to be protected from themselves. I defy him, or anyone, to find me a single person in this country who holds the view "I'm glad they have banned smoking in pubs because I never wanted to smoke in the pub, I only did it because it wasn't a crime". It is utterly absurd.

You will have to read his article to see just how confused and contradictory his argument is. I am reasonably sure I know why he says what he says. Here, again, I give him the benefit of the doubt and do not suggest that he is just putting forward a case which, if accepted, will keep him employed on a fat salary at the taxpayers' expense until his diet of salt-free tofu, fat-free lentils, assorted vegetation and additive-free water takes its toll. Nor do I suggest that he would ever be so hypocritical as to eat a diet containing other than salt-free tofu, fat-free lentils, assorted vegetation and additive-free water. Nor do I suggest he is a simple-minded ego-maniac determined to build his own little empire based on gathering power over the little people. Nor do I suggest that he is so arrogant that he thinks he knows better than Mr Ordinary how Mr Ordinary should live his life. Nor do I suggest that he has the capacity to see the contradictions in his own article. I think he says what he says because he has absolutely no understanding that life is about more than longevity.

That, of itself, makes his opinion completely worthless. Whether it also renders him unfit to hold the position he does is for others to decide.


Wednesday, 4 February 2009

Sustainable debt, the only practical course

Far more regularly than we might like to admit, we all face problems we have not encountered before. The first illness of the first child, the first time something arrives on our desk at work and we look at it thinking "oh dear, I don't know where to start", the first dripping tap or rotting window sill encountered as a homeowner with no landlord to call on for free help, the first time we exit Madam Fifi's Sauna and Hanky Panky Parlour to see our dearly beloved looking in the window of the shop next door. We have to decide what to do. We can try to tackle it ourselves (usually more in hope than expectation that we will find the right solution) or we can call for help from those who know more about the subject than us (or, in the last example, we can go back inside Madam Fifi's establishment until the risk has passed). What would have us committed to the local asylum, if such a thing still existed, would be denouncing other people's suggestions and then announcing publicly that we haven't got a clue what to do.

Welcome to the world of Gordon Brown. He has now admitted that he is stumbling around in the dark and simply guessing at how to deal with the current banking crisis.

Now let's go back about a year. At that time it had become clear that big banks in the UK and America had been making a lot of very bad loans and off-loading the risk to others, then buying the risk taken by other big banks. It was plainly a complete dog's breakfast. No one knew how much each bank was likely to lose by the time all the bad loans clucked home to roost, so each bank at risk manned the barricades and sought to limit their new business to very safe and secure transactions. While all this was going on, a few big banks had not engaged in the risky stuff and a lot of small banks, with shareholders who keep them on their toes, carried on as they had for decades lending only to good risks and keeping a perpetually beady eye on how each loan was performing. These prudent lenders have carried on much as before and are in just as sound a position today as they were before Mr and Mrs Ordinary first heard the term "Credit Default Swap".

The real problem with the international banker's beano in Davos is that it was an international bankers' beano. They are big wigs, grand fromages, doyens and doyennes with medals of all colours and nationalities to confirm their position as the banking creme de la creme. The politicians are scared of them because they have real power whether or not they deserve it. They can make or break their customers and they can make or break national economies. That necessarily means they can make or break political careers. It would take a true statesman to stand up to them and say "you made a right balls-up of this and now you must pay". Yet the only real power they have over politicians is the power of blackmail and that is diluted by the banks' current parlous states.

I have been hoping to hear a leading politician call their bluff and say to the banking aristocracy: "we are prepared to help you out to a limited degree but we require every penny of that help repaid with interest and you must cut your suit to match your cloth". You see, these banks are not doing us any favours by staying in business. They are not doing so because they think it is in the long term interests of Mr and Mrs Ordinary in Stoke Poges. They are staying in business because they think they will make a stonking great profit a few years down the line. If they thought they were irredeemably bust they would not stay in business, they would fold and let the losses lie where they fall regardless of how that affected any particular country's economy. In fact they know that a well run bank is a steady source of decent profits and a speculatively run bank can deliver massive short-term profits but only at the risk of long-term losses. That is the position they are in now. They speculated and appeared to win for a while but in doing so they build up a catalogue of debt which has proved to be corrosive. It is no surprise that it is corrosive, that has been proved time and again in the past and that is precisely why prudent bankers have never chased speculative short-term profits.

The reason they are fighting to stay in business is the very reason why taxpayers should not take on any of the risk that currently lies on their books. Either the banks will make profits from the business they are doing now or they will not. The business they did in the past has been done and cannot be reversed. It is tolerably clear that there are substantial losses in the system from that business, some of it has already surfaced and a lot more is waiting in the wings. Those losses have to fall somewhere they will not just disappear. There are only four possibilities. First, the losses are kept on the banks' books and are made good out of future profits. Second, the losses prove too heavy for the banks to bear and they fold, in which case investors in those banks lose the value of their investment (be it as shareholder or depositor, but subject to the £50,000 taxpayer-funded guarantee or personal deposits). Third, the banks are relieved of the debts by the government taking them on, in which case they still do not disappear they have to be made good from future taxes. Fourth, the government takes on the losses subject to a right of reimbursement from the banks' future profits.

None of these options is attractive, but that is unavoidable because vast losses are unattractive. The only difference between the first and second options is the future profitability of the banks concerned. Either they make it through the mess they have made or they don't, if they do the first option applies if not the second comes into play. I am attracted to these options because it will mean the gamblers have to take the risk inherent in their gambling. But there is a problem in piling all the loss on just one link in the chain of responsibility. The banks are not the only party to blame in this awful situation. Their activities were subject to supervision by the Financial Services Authority acting on the instructions laid down by poor Gordon when he was Chancellor of the Exchequer. Those of us with a bee in our bonnet about banks lending money to people who cannot afford to repay it get rather miffed to hear the government condemning irresponsible lending. The government was responsible for supervising the banks and, one might think, part of responsible supervision is to prevent irresponsible lending. So, why should the loss all fall on the banks and their investors when government is also to blame?

If we are to be fair about these things we have to accept not only that government was partly to blame but also that we, the electorate, put the government in place. I certainly didn't do so but I am bound by the decision of a general election, and long may that be the case whether or not I agree with the particular outcome. So, if we are to be fair, part of the loss should be borne by the great British public because the incompetent shower they placed in office are also to blame.

How much, then, should the taxpayer have to bear? This is not a matter for an arithmetical formula, it is a matter for looking at the thing in the round any trying to reach a balanced view. Already the taxpayer has taken out massive debts to help the banks restore their capital position and now we are in a recession hitting the little man hardest. It will be a long time before graphs start to turn north and by that time the taxpayer will have been landed with previously unimaginable amounts of debt. That seems a pretty fair price to me. From now on let the banks sink or swim. The level of business they do will determine not only their ability to make good losses on bad loans but also the extent of borrowing the people of this country can sustain.

Forget credit-funded stimulation of the economy, concentrate on what can actually be afforded. There is no point pretending we can live on credit to the level we did in 2005, 6 or 7 and seeking to boost lending back to those levels. If we can't afford it, we can't afford it. If we can afford it, that amount of credit will be advanced. That is not a decision for government it is a decision for individuals, businesses and prudent bankers. If the banks need a further kick-start by some of their losses being guaranteed with an obligation on the banks to repay anything the taxpayer has to fork out, then it can be considered as and when that position is reached. As I said above, they are not in business because they think they will continue to make losses, they know that they can make good profits if only they make good loans rather than bad loans; so any further financial assistance should come with protection for the taxpayer.