Wednesday, 4 March 2009

Has Gordon gone green?

In the course of a stuttering and nervous performance, the only things missing from poor Gordon's speech to the US Congress were handstands and wetting himself. He spewed out the usual panoply of meaningless soundbites with his customary lack of vision. Unlike his predecessor, poor Gordon cannot inspire through his delivery, he can only read a set script. The difficulty this causes him is that his words fall to be interpreted from the written page without the way they are spoken offering any insight into their true meaning. The BBC has helpfully published what purports to be the full speech (here). It is worth reading in full to see that he wasn't saying anything most of the time, Tony Blair's speeches read the same way but by listening to them you got a sense of meaning wholly missing from the printed words.

There was one thing poor Gordon said that caused me great trouble. The words cited by the BBC are these:
"... it is only by tackling climate change that we create the millions of new green jobs we need."

This really is a classic example of meaningless circular twaddle.

If we are to try to find some meaning in it we have to start by trying to spot a substantive proposition among the fluff. I think there is one, I think it is contained in these words "the millions of new ... jobs we need". He is certainly right in suggesting that millions of new jobs are needed, and you can leave America to one side, millions of new jobs are needed here in the UK as we already have almost two million people unemployed according to the official measure and at least the same again hidden by the selective nature of that measure.

So, we have a logical starting point, we need millions of new jobs. But this sensible proposition is qualified because he actually said "the millions of new green jobs we need". Why, pray, do we need millions of new green jobs rather than millions of any other colour of employment? The answer, of course, is that we don't. It's pure wibble. An unemployed person seeking to earn a living needs a job, any job. Green, black, blue or yellow with pink spots, it restores dignity into his life and puts food on the table. An income of £25,000 earned by making gas-guzzlers puts every bit as much food on the table as an income of £25,000 earned as a climate change interface consultant.

Having found a sensible proposition and seen it rendered senseless by an unnecessary and irrelevant adjective, we can then look at the first part of the phrase to see if that restores meaning. "It is only by tackling climate change that we can create the millions of new ... jobs we need" That is a logical proposition. Incorrect in fact, but internally consistent. If no jobs are available from any other source, they could, in theory, be created by projects to tackle climate change. But it is not his case, and could never be his case, that tackling climate change is the only source of new employment. So that can't be what he meant to say.

Let's see if it can be approached in another way by extracting different words. Try this: "It is only by tackling climate change that we can create ... millions of new green jobs". That works, but only if we have a definition of "green". Indeed, it works only if the definition of green is "a job that tackles climate change". If this is the correct interpretation, he said it is only by tackling climate change that we can create jobs tackling climate change. It's hard to disagree with that as a proposition, it is as true as saying it is only by tackling the lack of gas-guzzlers that we can create jobs making gas-guzzlers. It is true insofar as it goes, but it doesn't go very far because it merely states a truism more accurately expressed in reverse - it is only by creating jobs making gas-guzzlers that we can tackle the current lack of gas-guzzlers. Similarly, it is only by creating jobs tackling climate change that we can tackle climate change. Yet this doesn't express his full point because it makes no mention of the need for those jobs.

We can always test a proposition starting "it is only by doing X that Y can result" by asking what the position would be if we don't do X. Poor Gordon starts "it is only by tackling climate change" and then talks about jobs. So what will happen to jobs if we don't tackle climate change? Well, it rather depends on what you mean by "tackle climate change". He didn't say what he meant, which leaves us with an infinitely variable concept. Assuming he did not mean seeking to change solar output, the churning of the oceans, the speed of the winds or any other of the thousands of natural contributors to our climate, it is probably fair to infer that he meant the alleged influence of production of carbon dioxide by industrial processes and the use of such wickednesses as motor cars and aeroplanes. If that is right, it follows inevitably that jobs will be lost as industries are forced to increase their costs or close completely. So, if we don't tackle this aspect of climate change existing industrial jobs will be preserved and if we do tackle it existing industrial jobs will be lost. That's not a good start for an argument about the benefit to employment of tackling climate change.

Against this background of losing some existing industrial employment, where does poor Gordon's analysis stand? Having lost those jobs it is necessary to replace them but without the new jobs doing the evil that required the old jobs to go. Thus, we find a need for "millions of new green jobs". Yes, this is good, we have found a possible way in which there is a need for "millions of new green jobs". Ah, but there is a problem, the very thing that causes that need is said to be the creator of the "millions of new green jobs". No, that doesn't work. Tackling climate change in the manner I have identified creates a need for millions of new green jobs, but it does not create millions of new green jobs it merely destroys millions of old non-green jobs.

I have to admit defeat. I cannot find any sense in what poor Gordon said. His conversion to greenieness has been adjourned.


Sunday, 1 March 2009

From simple to sinister

It is now Sunday evening and many have already written about a most extraordinary explosion of brainless vitriol from the deputy leader of the Labour Party, simple Harriet Harman, nonetheless I will not be able to bring my blood pressure under control without saying my piece, so here it is.

This morning the Leader of the House of Commons and deputy leader of the Labour Party was interviewed on BBC television. Her interviewer was a tame poodle of the Labour Party, a man whose wife is not only the daughter of a former minister under the previous Labour government but also a close friend of the woman he was interviewing. This was undoubtedly a good thing. Some have bemoaned the lack of criticism in the questioning and the failure to follow-up daft answers with any sort of penetrative analysis of the weakness of those answers. They have a point, but they miss the real value of allowing someone like simple Harriet Harman to be interviewed by a receptive sponge. It allows her to say what she really thinks, safe in the knowledge that she will not be contradicted or challenged. And that allows us the chance to see how very dangerous she is.

She was asked about the pension arrangements of Sir Fred Goodwin, about which I bleated a couple of days ago (here). Her response (see BBC article here) was in three parts. First she said Sir Fred should not count on drawing his pension "because it is not going to happen", then "the Prime Minister has said that it is not acceptable and therefore it will not be accepted" and finally "it might be enforceable in a court of law, this contract, but it is not enforceable in the court of public opinion and that is where the government steps in". I doubt that she has any idea of the meaning of these three statements, so I'll see if I can help the poor cow.

Her first assertion, "it is not going to happen", a standard form of words used by mobsters. When I dealt with criminal work at the Bar I occasionally acted for people suspected of involvement in organised crime. Some of them had long criminal records and were very likely far more than merely suspected, a couple were later convicted of Mafia-like activities and all suspicion was removed. They operated their business by deciding in advance what the result should be and using any means at their disposal to achieve that result. A brothel is for sale and Robbie the Rasta wants to take it over, Big Terry the mobster says "that is not going to happen". The next day Robbie the Rasta is found to have sustained injuries to his knees and testicles from a number of baseball bats and Big Terry ends up in charge of the brothel. Well well, what a surprise. If you decree the result in advance you are placing yourself in the same camp as Big Terry because you are applying the same standards he applies.

Her second argument is even more worrying: "the Prime Minister has said that it is not acceptable and therefore it will not be accepted". Have we really descended to a state in which the Prime Minister can dictate whether individual transactions will be honoured? Have we really descended to a state in which a senior government minister can boast that we are subject to Prime Ministerial fiat? The sad thing is that we have been in that position for some time. So many laws now give ministers discretion to make major decisions without having to seek specific approval from Parliament that it is hardly surprising to find the government thinking the default position is for more and more matters to be subject to ad hoc exercises of ministerial discretion. None of the major recent decisions taken about the economy have been subject to Parliamentary scrutiny, or, if it comes to that, even of cabinet discussion. The Prime Minister and Chancellor of the Exchequer have decided between them to borrow and spend billions of pounds without anyone else having a say at all. Simple Harriet is merely taking that position one step further. Of necessity she has to be seen to support poor Gordon as he lurches from misjudgment to misjudgment. Her hero has within his power the right to hand over billions of pounds to RBS, so why shouldn't he be presumed to have the power to decide how £693,000 a year of that money is spent?

Her third proposition is the one which identifies just how deranged she now is. Remember that the basis of her point is that Sir Fred Goodwin has a legally enforceable contractual right to receive his pension; she is accepting for these purposes that he has a legal right to the money. Then she seeks to suggest that legal rights are subject to "the court of public opinion". Although she is pretty thick, it is hard to imagine she really believes this to be the case. But let's take her at her word, and assume she does believe it. What is "the court of public opinion"? Well, first it is not a court. In a court you have to argue a case against a background of laws. The law trumps everything. Public opinion is just that, the current state of opinion as measured by ... ah, there's the problem. Public opinion cannot be measured except by asking a sample of the public and extrapolating the balance of views held by that sample to find the general public opinion. It is not a reliable way to gauge anything because so much depends on the chosen sample and the framing of the question. And it can change tomorrow and the next day.

Let's put these two questions: (i) do you think Sir Fred Goodwin should receive a pension of £693,000 a year for life and (ii) do you think contracts should be upheld? And let's follow simple Harriet and assume the answer to the first question is in the negative. Public opinion can then be said to be in favour of preventing Sir Fred getting the dosh. It doesn't take a very prescient person to guess that the answer to the second question will be in the affirmative. So where does that leave "the court of public opinion"? It is giving contradictory rulings - that he should not receive the money and that he should receive the money. How do we resolve this conflict. That, it seems, is where the final part of her third proposition comes in. Not only did she say contracts are subject to "the court of public opinion" but went on to say "that is where the government steps in". But the government cannot step in to enforce the rulings of the "court of public opinion" because those rulings are contradictory. In other words she is not, in substance, arguing that public opinion should dictate whether a contract is enforced, she is saying the government should have this power. Seeking to justify her position by relying on public opinion is just a smokescreen.

The position she puts forward is deeply sinister, but it is also consistent with everything she has ever stood for and argued for. She is a dedicated Marxist for whom The State can do no wrong. The arbitrary exercise of power is an inevitable outcome of The State being more important than the people. Simple Harriet is far too stupid to think through what she says, she is in a blind panic to keep her career alive by appealing to the basest instincts of her core supporters. Her absurd comments will come back to haunt her. In the meantime I look forward to her making a bigger even arse of herself when she has to back-track, as she undoubtedly will.


Saturday, 28 February 2009

Whither the national interest?

Back in the dim and distant past of the pre-New Labour era we used to hear a lot about the balance of payments and the national interest. They were central to government policy yet they have now both disappeared from view.

The balance of payments was the difference between the value of stuff we exported and the value of stuff we imported. Figures were broadcast every month for tangibles and invisibles. Very often we were in the red in tangibles (actual things like cars and cabbages) but in the black for invisibles (such as banking and insurance). It mattered because we were competing against other countries and needed to know how we were doing. At least we thought we needed to know, that we don't get any figures these days suggests it might not have been necessary at all.

Except that it was necessary. It was necessary so we could judge whether we were getting things right or wrong. Just as a business needs to know whether it is making a profit or a loss in order to be able to judge its performance and make any necessary changes, so the country needs to know the same if it is to address systemic problems in the economy. Of course the figures have been available, they just haven't been published as widely as they used to be.

The national interest was the overriding concern of government, however dismally any individual government protected it. The UK government held a mandate from the people of the UK and felt it necessary to act in what it perceived to be the best interests of the UK. If France or Germany or, if it comes to that, Swaziland proposed something considered detrimental to this country the government would speak against it. Act against it less often, but speak against it every time. The concept of the national interest recognised that we are in competition with other countries. It also recognises that the first priority of the UK government should be to protect the interests of the people of the UK.

We just don't hear about the national interest these days and we don't hear about how well or badly this country is doing in its economic dealing with other countries. Instead we hear all about global this and European that, as though every other country is governed to protect the interests of international organisations and ideals rather than its own people. It's ok, we needn't worry, the EU or the UN will come to our rescue if something goes wrong. All we need to do it strengthen these bodies and we need never worry about anything again. This strikes me as a peculiar way to go about things and to be fundamentally wrong both in fact and in principle.

It is wrong in fact because many governments are assiduous in protection of what they consider their national interest, the USA and France are perhaps the most obvious examples of this but it goes far wider than that. Do you think the former soviet-bloc countries have joined the EU out of a sense of altruism or to further the political strength of the EU Parliament and Commission? Of course they haven't, they have joined because they see it as potentially beneficial for their people. Beneficial in two ways. First by giving them access to markets across Europe without the handicap or import taxes or restrictions on the right to work, and secondly by giving them access to hand-outs from the EU's pot of gold. If they were to become net contributors they wouldn't give a second's thought to joining the EU. They joined because they considered it in their own national interest to do so.

The reason relying on more and more international bodies to provide protection in times of difficulty is wrong in principle is that standards differ about what is a difficulty and what is the right way out of it. It's easy enough with something like NATO, a military alliance, because dealing with a military threat does not (except in the most esoteric way) involve cultural values and different interpretations of what is a threat and what is beneficial. Once diplomacy fails, either you shoot back or you get massacred; having more people with guns on your side is plainly beneficial. But you can't apply the same universal standard to economic or social matters. What areas of the economy should the government be involved in, what part should government play in sports or the arts, how should health care be funded, how should children be educated? There is simply no single answer on which everyone can agree. What is acceptable to the people of one country can be wholly unacceptable to another because of their differing history and culture.

Once decisions are passed to an international body it can become a supra-national body. Instead of being a meeting point for heads of government to see what common ground they can establish (as is still he case with NATO, for example), the body itself starts to form its own agenda and countries are required to fall into line or suffer sanctions. Instead of EU policy being a summary of those things all the member nations agree on, it is now something the member states are required to comply with whether they agree with it or not. This creates both practical and political problems.

On the practical side we have such things as current EU laws and directives on so-called health and safety. Health and safety is a balancing exercise between risk and reward. You can't just say "you must reduce the risk in this way" if that impacts so much on the reward as to make the whole exercise onerous or pointless. Of course people sometimes fall off ladders or chairs when changing a light bulb but the risk is pretty small, to require the erection of a scaffold tower and for all around them to stop work and stand well clear would be disproportionate to the risk. Did you know you cannot lawfully change a light fitting in your kitchen or bathroom without having the work certified by a properly qualified person? That's all very well for Mr Rich who would hire an electrician to do it anyway, but it's onerous for Mr Poor who saved for weeks to buy a nice light fitting and now has to fork out the same amount again for someone to fit it or check how he has carried out the most simple of jobs. There is no single standard of what is appropriate for everyone in all circumstances. Yet the more powers that are passed from national governments to supra-national bodies the more uniformity will be required and the more cases there will be of central edicts being inappropriate or absurd when put into practice.

The political problem arises from the inevitable democratic deficit of these bodies not being answerable directly to the people their decisions affect. This breeds mistrust because people don't remember the things the body got right only the things they got wrong. An ever-growing list of perceived errors combined with no effective means of changing the membership or policies of the body, can result in widespread discontent. Think back to 1979 and 1997. In each of those years a stale government was ousted and the result was that the very people who felt most let-down by the old were invigorated by the new. Yet how much actually changed about overall government policy on the 4th of May 1979 and the 2nd of May 1997? Twenty percent, ten percent, five percent? Maybe not even five percent. What changed was the general emphasis of policy much more than its details and, most importantly, all the failings of the old governors were sent out of the door and the new lot started with a clean slate. Between 1979 and 1997 the Conservative's slate filled with chalk dust, bits of fluff and dried chewing gum, and between 1997 and today Labour's slate has undergone the same transition. The mere fact that we voted to change our governing party gave continuing legitimacy to the whole system. Without the possibility of such change it is inevitable that legitimacy will disappear, thereby negating the only thing any government can rely on as its ultimate authority.

The aftermaths of the 1979 and 1997 general elections also show that there can be a radical change in certain basic aspects of policy to correct systemic problems encountered with the established way of doing things. Mrs Thatcher's central message in 1979 was that the old way of doing things wasn't working. The country was bankrupt and she argued for business and industry to be allowed to show what it could do without some of the centrally-imposed constraints which had become the norm. Not everyone agreed with her. It was essentially a matter of opinion not fact, but enough agreed with her to allow her to be given a chance to put her ideas into practice. Something else was tried because the former consensus no longer held sway. A similar change occurred after the 1997 election. Mr Blair argued that The State was doing too little and could do more to improve peoples lives. Sufficient agreed with him for his ideas to be put into practice. The system allowed new ideas to be put into practice because the old ones were no longer perceived as appropriate to modern life. Today there seems to be a sizeable body of public opinion that a change is needed again and an opportunity to vote for change will arise within the next fourteen months. We learn what works and what does not work by trying new things and seeing what effect they have. Even if 95% of policy remains essentially the same from one government to the next, the other five percent can make a huge difference - perhaps beneficial, perhaps not, that's a matter of opinion; there is always another election coming along for those who make a case against the incumbents.

How do you change the policies of a supra-national organisation when the existing ones do not suit the people of a particular country? The answer, of course, is that you can't. It is inevitably one-size-fits-all, like-it-or-lump-it; uniformity is seen as a benefit in its own right regardless of its practical effects. We often hear government ministers saying they are merely implementing EU policy when something daft or unpopular is brought in, as though that is an excuse. To my mind it shows the great problem with removing powers from Westminster and giving them to Brussels. Not only is there no way of giving EU government new legitimacy when it has lost our confidence but there is no effective way of changing EU policies that don't work.

Through all of this, we little people are concerned with how things affect our lives. Those who live in a village are concerned about how political decisions will affect their village, townsfolk and city dwellers ask the same about their town or city, they all do the same again when county-wide issues arise and we all do it on matters that affect the whole country. The national interest is not a political fiction, it is a reflection of the real concerns of the little people. When a factory closes in Birmingham there is a problem for those who lose their jobs and for those whose businesses and jobs depend on the Birmingham factory (such as shops close to the factory who relied on trade from the workers as they arrived and left each day). It is also a problem for the UK as a whole because increased domestic unemployment reduces UK tax revenue and increases the claims made on UK taxpayers. It has no effect whatsoever in Paris, Frankfurt or Warsaw, and the governments of France, Germany and Poland are too busy trying to protect their own people to worry about it.

Even though we are trapped within the money-sucking vampire known as the EU, we still have a national interest and there are still a few ways in which it can be promoted. Currently, all over Europe, national interests are being asserted afresh from the bottom-up. More of the same centralised power cannot answer these interests because British, French, German, Polish and all other EU manufacturers and other businesses are not playing for the same team, they are in direct competition. Our countries as economic units are also in direct competition.

I hope we hear a lot more about the UK national interest in the run-up to the next election. It is far too important to be left in the hands of the EU or the UN. We are best at deciding what is right for us. We might not be very good at it, but we still do a far better job than any unaccountable body concerned more with its own power than with improving life for us.


Friday, 27 February 2009

A very political pension

It is hard to understand how we reached the current position of Sir Fred Goodwin and his unfeasibly large pension. For anyone who doesn't know the background, Sir Fred was the head of the Royal Bank of Scotland until late last year. Under his stewardship a successful bank was reduced to a pile of steaming debt, posting losses of £24.1billion in the latest financial year. His bank was at risk of folding in 2008 until the government stepped in with vast sums of money and propped up its sagging cadaver. As part of the rescue package it was thought best for Sir Fred to concentrate on mastering crochet and flower-arranging, so his exit from the bank was negotiated. As with all negotiations, his departure came only when both he and the government were satisfied with the terms agreed. He did not insist on being paid in lieu of notice and he gave up certain other entitlements, including his key to the executive lavatory, in return the government thanked him and asked him to close the door on his way out.

The government had two other options. One was to let the bank fold, a course which would have terminated Sir Fred's contract of employment and restricted the amount of money he could get out of the company in the future, but that was thought unacceptable. The other was to sack him and let him sue if he didn't like it. There is only one good reason for not sacking someone who has overseen the total collapse of a previously successful business, and that is that you cannot prove he broke the terms of his contract of employment. Sir Fred was sought out by the bank to be it's big cheese. One consequence of being head-hunted for a major position is that you are very much in the driving seat when it comes to the terms of your employment. It would not be at all surprising if his contract of employment was drafted in terms very favourable to him. Indeed it might well be that his only concrete obligation was to receive his salary and bonuses. Various other obligations would be implied by law even if not expressly included, but each of them would be a difficult basis on which to justify dismissal even for the man responsible for snapping the bank's spine in two.

All this should have been looked into when the government took a majority shareholding in the bank and had to decide what to do about Sir Fred. In fact, even from this most incompetent of governments, it is inconceivable that it was not looked into. A deal was done and that was that. Sir Fred visited the yarn shop and started the crocheted blanket of his dreams. Now news has broken that his pension entitlement is no less than £693,000 a year for life, he is currently fifty years old, and the government is embarrassed. I have to say, I would be embarrassed if I had negotiated the removal from office of someone who had done so much damage and had managed to leave him with a pension pot valued at some £16million. I would ask how I could have been so incompetent.

An exchange of letters has now taken place between Sir Fred Goodwin and Lord Myners, the minister responsible for the negotiation. Sir Fred pointed out that he gave up the equivalent of more than a year's fat salary, that the pension was all recorded on the books and that the minister agreed to him keeping it. In reply the minister said he had believed the pension to be a legal entitlement whereas it now appears it was only discretionary. With the level of skill enjoyed by only this government in the western world, a minister's excuse makes him appear even more incompetent.

When the negotiation was taking place Sir Fred had a legal entitlement to a year's notice yet he agreed to forgo that entitlement, he had a legal entitlement to other benefits and agreed to forgo them, so why would the fact that the minister believed his National Lottery sized pension to be a legal entitlement mean it was not up for negotiation? It makes no sense.

But that's not the worst bit. The worst bit is that the minister did not know the legal status of the pension arrangement. These things are not written in hieroglyphics, they are contracts in pretty standard English legal jargon. They include a chunk setting out the terms on which the pension is payable. If you want to know what it means, the conventional technique is to read it.

None of this is to say that Sir Fred cannot be deprived of his ginormous pension, although it is very unlikely. Poor Gordon, at his most monocular and moronic, has started shouting about seeking ways to prevent at least part of it being paid. Even the grossly over-pensioned John Prescott has weighed-in, calling for Sir Fred to be summarily deprived of the money and putting the onus on him to sue for it. Not for him the rule of law or the law of contract, the idiot Prescott has votes to win so he wants to make the law up as he goes along if he thinks it will result in little crosses against the names of Labour Party candidates come election day.

It's all just political posturing, of course. If the government is to have any chance of undoing the arrangement within the law they face an enormous obstacle in their agreement to the severance package negotiated last year. Obviously we cannot tell exactly what happened. Maybe Sir Fred was given a generous pay-off because of his years of loyal service to the furtherance of poor Gordon's grand economic plan, and this little spat is the price he has to pay for his future income. Maybe he felt he had given up enough by waiving his notice period and other benefits and would never have agreed to cede his pension without a legal battle he felt confident of winning. Maybe the whole negotiation was just conducted utterly incompetently by a government that was in full headless chicken mode at the time. Whatever the true position, one simple fact remains - a deal was done.

And that is where the really important lesson comes from this farce. If it had been Barclays Bank or HSBC that took over RBS rather than the government, there would be no row about Sir Fred's pension arrangements. They would have been part of a the whole takeover package and lost in the small print while the real business of trying to rebuild a once thriving bank would be the only concern. Instead the state of the bank has been relegated to secondary importance behind an issue of no real consequence to anything. That is what happens when governments take over businesses. Headlines and opinion polls are more important to them than the substance of the thing. OK, so his pension pot is worth £16million, a huge amount of money for an individual, but what is it in relation to RBS as a whole? Its losses for the year were £24.1billion and his pension entitlement grew over several years, but let's treat it as a single part of the £24.1billion loss in that single year. £16million is 0.067% of £24.1billion. Heap all the vitriol you want on the man, he had to go, he had presided over ruination, get rid of him. Pay him 0.067% of the losses the bank incurred in his final year and send him on his way, it will be money well spent. Just start running the bloody thing properly.

Yet they will not run it properly. They will run it for political gain. They think there is political capital - by which I mean potential votes - in shouting about how much the failed former boss of the bank is being paid. They might be right, but it's got nothing to do with anything. If they were really concerned about it as a matter of high principle they could have written clauses into his severance contract ensuring he did not receive that money. The issue has cropped up now as a matter of pure political convenience. Just as poor Gordon is getting flak from national and international figures about the way he bankrupted the country he has found a subject to divert attention. It won't divert it for long and in a few weeks or months there will be another scapegoat put up to receive public fury, anything to prevent the government that bankrupted the country being identified as the cause of our bankruptcy.

We saw earlier in the week how Northern Rock is now to be used to make home-purchase loans for political reasons (here). Today the effective nationalisation of RBS is the excuse for trying to win some votes by bashing a man with money. Tomorrow it will be something else. There are endless ways in which attaching government to business allows politicians to engage in populist rants by picking a random example of how the business works, taking it out of context and flogging it for all it's worth.

Oh, and lest you might believe that I approve of Sir Fred's pension arrangements, I don't. But I would rather see contractual arrangements upheld than arbitrary rule according to the temporary direction of the political wind. Maybe we have laws to hold reckless incompetents like Sir Fred Goodwin to account for the vast damage they do, maybe we don't. Maybe that will never be tested. But I would rather he got away with scamming £16million under a freely negotiated contract than we have rule by populist diktat.


Thursday, 26 February 2009

"All of time is squeeze margin down no profit"

I learn a lot by talking to those who run small businesses. By the way isn't "small businesses" a horrible term? It makes them sound unimportant when they are actually the backbone of the economy. But I digress, and that's not good when it happens in the second sentence of a piece, so I must return to topic double quick.

Yesterday evening was great fun. Being a day ending in Y, there was nothing on the telly so it seemed a good day to eat out and curry seemed just the ticket. It's a good stroll to the closest local curry houses. I say houses because there are two next door to each other. One has been there for as long as anyone can remember, the other started ten or so years ago, and both have always enjoyed excellent reputations. My custom always went to the longer established place for the simple reason that I went there before it's competitor set up in business. When the old couple who ran it decided to retire their restaurant was bought by the people next door. Not because they particularly wanted to expand but to ensure that a new and aggressive competitor would not enter the fray. Now they operate two different restaurants next door to each other but will convert into one large establishment when the time is right.

On the waddle home it was necessary to pop into the greengrocers to top up my stocks of vegetable and fruit based products, on this occasion cigarettes and cider. The owner was bemoaning the presence a few doors away of a new competitor who took over a small failing off-licence and stocked it well with a range of general grocery products (including cheap large tins of fruit in sticky syrup). The newcomer isn't doing a lot of trade, in fact I would be surprised if he lasts a year, but it is a worry nonetheless for the established shopkeeper. To seek to maintain his hold on the local market he has undercut his new competitor with special offers on beer and wines, cutting deep into his own modest profit margin.

Both the owners of the curryhouses and the owner of the greengrocery have seen their takings fall considerably over the last year. They both told me they cannot see enough business for more than one shop of their type in the immediate vicinity. Part of me thinks "they would say that, wouldn't they?" but I think there is actually more to it. These are people who know their market well, they talk to their customers and gauge the mood. When the greengrocers tells me, through his thick Turkish accent, "all of time is squeeze margin down no profit" I am inclined to believe him. When he tells me "1990 business stay good, 1980 business stay good, this time no, this time worst", I am inclined to believe him. When a restaurant proprietor who set up in business next to an established rival and saw both businesses do well tells me he cannot see enough trade for both to make a living in the medium to long term, I am inclined to believe him, particularly because he opened his shop just after the last recession.

This sort of anecdotal evidence doesn't prove anything concrete, but it does give a hint that real businessmen see something different about this recession. They see it as something that will change spending patterns for a long time to come. I suspect they are right and would certainly trust their judgment more than that of any number of academic economists who have never actually put a bank note in a till or paid a member of staff.


Tuesday, 24 February 2009

Mr Darling hits Rock bottom

Yesterday the government decided to abandon all sense and enter the home mortgage market through its puppet bank, Northern Rock. As you will probably know, Northern Rock got itself into difficulties through a pincer movement of spectacular irresponsibility. It made huge numbers of advances without making proper enquiries into the borrowers' ability to service the loans and advanced a very high proportion of the perceived value of the properties given as security; in many instances it advanced far more than the perceived value of the property. That was the first line - bad loans. In order to fund these loans it had to get its hands on money, much of which it borrowed from other financial institutions over short periods of time. When wholesale credit became harder to find, it still had to repay existing borrowing despite not being able to lay its hands on replacement funds at an affordable price. That was the second line - over-reliance on temperamental sources of funds. The difficulty in securing new funds was made worse by the fact that its mortgage book was stuffed full of dodgy loans, thereby giving rise to doubt whether it would be able to repay any new funding. We covered all of that a few months ago.

Northern Rock borrowed £27billion from the Treasury in 2007. That's an awful lot of money. After being nationalised the bank effectively stopped making new loans and concentrated on turning existing loans into cash to repay the £27billion. To its credit, so far it has repaid around £18billion. This money has come from two main sources. Existing borrowers have continued to make repayments (albeit with high levels of default), giving a cash flow that has not been re-lent; and many have been encouraged to remorgage with other banks so that their borrowings from Northern Rock were repaid. In effect, it was losing the chance of future profits but securing repayment of the capital sums advanced. It has also taken quite an aggressive position with accounts that have gone into arrears and have repossessed and sold properties quickly to prevent losses on those accounts getting even worse. All fairly standard stuff when you are winding-down a business.

I'm no genius, but I reckon repayment of £18billion out of £27billion leaves £9billion plus interest still to be paid back to the Treasury. Some might think the government's first priority would be to get this money so as to make a small dent in its own unaffordable debt. But no, now Mr Darling thinks Northern Rock should start lending money again and is suspending further repayments to allow the bank to make new loans. We wait to see the lending criteria applied, but the indication is that they will be more generous to borrowers than most other banks.

The other banks have reverted to the historically stable formula of limiting loans to 75% or 80% of the perceived value of the property offered as security and advancing only limited multiples of the borrower's income. They have done so for three reasons. The first is that they need to know they are writing sound business because these new loans will be a substantial part of their income stream from which to cover losses which are still waiting in the system but have not yet attached their mandibles to the pin-striped posterior. The second is because they don't have as much cash to lend as they used to, so they can be more selective and advance it on only the soundest deals. The third is that there is no longer a race to the bottom in which they all think they must lend hither-and-yon because their competitors will do so and make profits if they don't. There simply aren't the borrowers out there willing to buy in a falling market.

What is happening now is an interesting example of the extent to which house prices were previously inflated not by genuine demand but by the availability of unsustainable loans. Classic supply-and-demand theory states that where supply is greater than demand prices fall because the buyer is in the driving seat, he knows he can buy elsewhere if one seller doesn't give him the right price; and where demand is greater than supply prices rise because the supplier dictates the price, either the buyer pays it or he misses out because another buyer will pay it. Of course it is far more complex than that because there are numerous factors at play other than a simple numerical comparison between the number of things available and the number of people wanting to buy them. For example, people might be willing to pay more in a local shop than they would at the supermarket three miles away because it is more convenient, and some wouldn't be seen dead in Tesco so they shop at Waitrose instead even though it is more expensive.

One of the major factors affecting house prices is the amount of money potential purchasers have available. Even where numerical demand far exceeds supply, buyers can only pay what they can pay. That five people might each offer £200,000 for a particular property does not necessarily mean the seller can get another £5,000 out of any of them, if they only have £200,000 then £200,000 is the ceiling. It goes without saying that the ceiling will rise if potential buyers can borrow more. Say you have Mr Ordinary on a salary of £30,000. When lending is limited to three times his salary the most he can borrow is £90,000. Applying a laxer standard and allowing him to borrow five times salary means he can lay his hands on £150,000. Not surprisingly, the more he can borrow the more he can afford to offer but that does not mean he can afford a larger property because every potential purchaser is in the same position. Those looking for a one-bedroomed flat can afford more, as can those seeking a two-up-two-down, as can the three-bed semi crowd and those desirous of a five-bed detached with low-level suite in duck-egg blue. Prices all along the chain get pushed-up a few notches simply because banks are prepared to lend more.

Over the last year or so relatively few new house purchase loans were made while the banks reassessed their lending criteria. No doubt part of the slow rate of business was caused by many purchasers deciding to wait and see what will happen to prices over the next year or more, but a part was, nonetheless, due to the banks being extremely cautious. That caution has now translated into the new standard of lending criteria, requiring substantial deposits and applying not just limits to the multiple applied to income but also more stringent assessments of the security of the borrower's income. Now that a new standard has been applied the banks are lending more than they did in 2008. In exactly the same way that their lending was suicidally lax over the preceding few years, leading to far too many unserviceable loans being made, so it was tighter than long-term interests required in 2008 while they reassessed their options.

I can see some sense of Northern Rock re-entering the mortgage market and applying the same strict but sustainable lending criteria applied by the other banks. This would produce valuable assets which could be used to service the outstanding government loans, but only if enough sound new business is done to provide sufficient income to service those loans. What I find difficult is that Mr Darling has already announced that mortgages up to 90% of valuation will be made available. The other banks aren't doing this because they perceive it to be unduly risky in these turbulent times. If Northern Rock is to trade its way out of trouble, one would think the last thing it should do is take risks other banks are not prepared to take. Nor does it seem to make much sense to try to trade your way out of trouble when you have already disposed of much of your existing sound business in order to repay two-thirds of an enormous government loan unless what remains is viable as a business in its own right. It seems highly unlikely that it is viable because it has not been able to shift the bad loans which are defaulting at a very high rate.

In order to re-enter the mortgage market Northern Rock needs money. Having repaid £18billion to the government by cashing-in its existing good business, it is now going to borrow up to another £14billion in order to make loans on less sound terms than most of those they have disposed of. On the face of it the whole thing is bananas. It's bananas for Northern Rock which will then be in hock to the government for up to £23billion with no obvious means of repaying this sum other than selling-off every sound loan it still holds and all the loans it is about to make. And it's bananas for the Treasury which needs to find ways to reduce its own borrowings rather than terminating repayments from a debtor and lending that very debtor yet more.

There is only one possible reason for this move. It is to maintain the existing part of the house-price bubble (if not to re-inflate it to former levels) by challenging the other banks to match Northern Rock's new lax lending criteria. If those other banks are foolish enough to do so the result will be substantial additional funds being made available to potential purchasers with the inevitable result of prices being kept higher than they would otherwise be. It overlooks the need for house-purchase to be affordable and, therefore, sustainable and, therefore, a stable force in the economy. Lend too much and prices are pushed up. Lend too much and the level of default will be high. This risks lenders suffering capital losses which will have to be passed onto their customers which will make the cost of credit high, which will risk yet further defaults.

The idea of lending more to "stimulate" the housing market so as to aid recovery from recession is fundamentally flawed. It will not aid the way out of recession because it will not create new wealth, it will just create new pretend wealth (as to which see my offering of yesterday). There will also be marginal benefits in an increase in trade in carpets, corkscrews and Swedish flat-pack furniture, but that will be dwarfed by the longer term stifling effect of the house price bubble being extended. And, at the same time, it will increase government debt yet further thereby prolonging the post-recession period in which real growth is reduced or nullified by the additional taxes needed to repay that debt.

Mr Darling does not seem to realise that this country's systemic economic problem cannot be cured by the creation of more pretend money.


Monday, 23 February 2009

A special lie from poor Gordon

The Labour Party has started a new website using taxpayers' money, it claims to be a site giving unbiased information and so is dressed as a government site and paid for by the little people. In fact it is just Labour Party propaganda. This is such an abuse of office that I do not intend to compound the insult by linking to it or mentioning its name. But I do want to look at something poor Gordon has written on it.

There is a section about the current recession/depression in which the man pretending to be Prime Minister explains what caused it and how it should be solved. He says this:
"In America people were encouraged to buy homes with cheap credit and low starter interest rates, but salespeople made no proper assessment of what level of lending they could afford to repay.
As US house prices fell and the US economy slowed the number of people defaulting on their mortgage started to rise, and once other lenders realised that was happening, the system started to panic, as everyone was trying to work out how many other risky assets the other banks held.
"

This is so blatantly simplistic and inaccurate that some might be surprised to find it being put forward by anyone who claims to know what they are talking about. How can he possibly think it a fair and accurate summary of the position? How can he seek to explain the situation in the UK by exclusive reference to what happened in America? The man is clearly now so deluded that all hope of hearing sense from him has passed.

The case he seeks to put forward is that there is no problem anywhere other than America and all losses being suffered by banks are the result of defaults by US housebuyers. The man is absolutely barking. It is certainly true that American banks lent money left-right-and-centre to people who couldn't afford the loans, they had to because of a bizarre legal requirement imposed first by Jimmy Carter and then strengthened by Bill Clinton required them to do so as a condition of being granted a banking licence. But what about here in the UK? The same thing was done by many of our banks voluntarily, in pursuit of a quick profit, with the agreement and encouragement of the government. Our houses did not become grossly overpriced because of anything going on in America, our economy is not saddled with countless billions of unaffordable credit card debt because of anything going on in America, our businesses are not burdened by expensive red tape because of anything going on in America; only someone with prawn cocktail for brains could think otherwise.

I've said it before and, being a boring sort of chap, I'll say it again, levels of perceived wealth over the last few years comprised both real wealth and pretend money, money which did not really exist. That pretend money is now being squeezed out of the system. That's what recessions do, they bring us back to reality when we have been living beyond our means on pretend money. Sadly, lancing the boil of fictitious wealth can destroy real wealth in the process, collateral damage cannot be avoided.

I know poor Gordon is an avid reader of my musings, and I now know he has prawn cocktail for brains, so I will illustrate things in terms even he might understand. Take Mr Ordinary on a post-tax income of £12,000. That means, Gordon, that he has £1,000 to spend each month. Rent costs him £500 a month, gas, electricity, food, travel and clothing cost him £450 a month. He has £50 a month spare. Mr Ordinary wants a car, it will cost £6,000 but he doesn't have the cash so he takes out a loan. It costs £75 a month. Woops, he has a problem. He is now a man with a car, ostensibly a wealthier man than he was last month because then he was a man without a car. He maintains his spending as before and soon finds himself overdrawn at the bank. How can this be? He is now wealthier than he was before, how can he also be poorer? The answer, of course, is that his apparent additional wealth is an illusion. Eventually the time will come when he has to cut back on his spending to balance the books. But, and here is the vital point, it will not be enough just to reduce spending by £25 a month because that will only restore him to a break-even position for the future. He also has to repay the overdraft. In order to negate the loss caused by taking out an unaffordable loan he will have to reduce his normal expenditure to below £1,000 a month until the overdraft is cleared. During that period of hardship his real wealth falls, he started out with £1,000 to spend on himself but for a time he has to spend less than that and suffer a real reduction in the quality of life.

That's what recession is all about, not just reducing your current expenditure to match your income but reducing it to below your established comfort level in order to remove the accumulated cost of having lived beyond your means. It applies to a country just as it applies to Mr Ordinary in this example because a national economy is made up of the individual economies of the people and businesses operating within it.

In one respect the problem of American banks being obliged to lend to the indigent has made things worse in that those British banks that invested in securitised US homeloans face losses that also need to to be addressed. The problem, however, is not that the US banks made bad loans and offered British banks the opportunity to buy an interest in those loans, it is that the British banks accepted the offer. Canadian banks did not, because their regulator did not allow it; accordingly Canadian banks are now sitting pretty. Pointing the finger at America is no answer. When someone offers me a pie and my decision to eat the pie follows encouragement from a dietician, the resultant clogging of my arteries cannot sensibly be laid at the door of the person offering me lard and dripping wrapped in a crisp suet crust. It was my choice to eat it and that choice was subject to the ultimate quality control of the dietician. In real life such a dietician would require good insurance. In the fantasy world of Labour politics they make him Prime Minister.